Live data from Hacker News

Google Earth Reverse Engineering

github.com

1–10 of 38 posts

Re: Google Earth Reverse Engineering

#3
I'm so glad that this has been made, I tried working on something like this a while ago but gave up after struggling for a bit. At the time I was surprised it didn't exist yet.

I'm wondering though if Google'll eventually patch things so this doesn't work, or if they're not too bothered by people grabbing data like this.

Re: Google Earth Reverse Engineering

#6
"Reverse engineering" seems a bit pointless when Google has open sourced the code for Google Earth Enterprise:

https://github.com/google/earthenterprise

(Update: The client was not open sourced, just the server.)

However, this doesn't give you carte blanche to use Google's own imagery:

https://maps.google.com/help/terms_maps.html

Re: Google Earth Reverse Engineering

#7

I hope this gets mirrored somewhere else, because I don't trust GitHub to not cave in to legal demands despite RE being legal regardless of EULA in parts of the world, and the extra attention this gets may otherwise kill it.

From what I've seen, GitHub will only respond to a DMCA request for takedown, and Google very rarely files those (I think I saw one in the GitHub DMCA notice repo for an entire internal published source repo once, could be misremembering). Google doesn't usually fight with lawyers instead of tech (e.g. making scraping more difficult).

Not saying you shouldn't fork or fear, but GitHub and Google are generally good actors compared to others.

Re: Google Earth Reverse Engineering

#9
post #6

"Reverse engineering" seems a bit pointless when Google has open sourced the code for Google Earth Enterprise: https://github.com/google/earthenterprise (Update: The client was not open sourced, just the server.) However, this doesn't give you carte blanche to use Google's own imagery: https://maps.google.com/help/terms_maps.html

I wonder why the latest release is over 800MB compressed... I doubt that includes the actual imagery either.

Re: Google Earth Reverse Engineering

#10
post #6

"Reverse engineering" seems a bit pointless when Google has open sourced the code for Google Earth Enterprise: https://github.com/google/earthenterprise (Update: The client was not open sourced, just the server.) However, this doesn't give you carte blanche to use Google's own imagery: https://maps.google.com/help/terms_maps.html

That project seems to use some other kind of API. It does not handle real octree/3d data AFAIK. I've only seen quadtree and terrain elevation stuff there.
Post reply on HN