Live data from Hacker News

Anonymous Google Employees Voted Arms Control Persons of the Year

armscontrol.org

1–10 of 159 posts

Re: Anonymous Google Employees Voted Arms Control Persons of the Year

#4
post #3

But yet all 4,000 of them still work for the largest surveillance corporation that has ever existed. At least now they think they have the moral high ground.

They track us in real-time down to a meter, predict when and where we will travel, know who we interact with, know our DNA[1], know what food we like, when we are sick, what our political leanings are, can predict what our children will like / dislike and probably can predict when we'll die...

If any of that isn't completely true yet, it will be.

[1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/23andme-is-terrif...

Re: Anonymous Google Employees Voted Arms Control Persons of the Year

#6
Unfortunately, the divide between Silicon Valley and the Pentagon will be bad for national security in the long run. Recent news cycles keep revealing yet another piece military equipment suffering from software weaknesses. Technology does not stand still, if Russia and China have more of their most talented engineers willing to work on national projects than us that will inevitably lead to a competence gap.

Here is an interesting article about the cultural divide and how it can be mediated:

https://www.defenseone.com/ideas/2018/12/divide-between-sili...

Re: Anonymous Google Employees Voted Arms Control Persons of the Year

#7
post #3

But yet all 4,000 of them still work for the largest surveillance corporation that has ever existed. At least now they think they have the moral high ground.

It occurs to me that attacking people who are probably on your side, and are in a position to influence Google's policies, is probably not the most effective way of enacting change.

Unless your real argument is "Everyone's evil so don't bother trying".

Re: Anonymous Google Employees Voted Arms Control Persons of the Year

#8
post #4
post #3

But yet all 4,000 of them still work for the largest surveillance corporation that has ever existed. At least now they think they have the moral high ground.

They track us in real-time down to a meter, predict when and where we will travel, know who we interact with, know our DNA[1], know what food we like, when we are sick, what our political leanings are, can predict what our children will like / dislike and probably can predict when we'll die... If any of that isn't completely true yet, it will be. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/23andme-is-terrif...

That's true and it's terrible. But they are not building actual weapons that kill people. That's worth something.

Re: Anonymous Google Employees Voted Arms Control Persons of the Year

#10
post #6

Unfortunately, the divide between Silicon Valley and the Pentagon will be bad for national security in the long run. Recent news cycles keep revealing yet another piece military equipment suffering from software weaknesses. Technology does not stand still, if Russia and China have more of their most talented engineers willing to work on national projects than us that will inevitably lead to a competence gap. Here is…

That's probably true, but the blame belongs squarely on the government.

Edit: Not clear why this is getting so many downvotes. If the government is not trustworthy, people won't want to cooperate with the government. Demanding that they put aside their ethics for the sake of patriotism/national security/etc., while ignoring their legitimate concerns, is pure propaganda.

Post reply on HN