Live data from Hacker News

‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

vulture.com

1–10 of 130 posts

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#2
The catastrophe in 12 Monkeys is due to the action of a single individual - an ideologue concerned with the "biosphere". The pathology highlighted is ideological thought that justifies mass murder.

Love certainly conquers all in this film. It is precisely love (here romantic love) that weaves an unalterable thread through time and binds the two individuals who are absolutely necessary for the future salvation of mankind.

"I’ve been thinking about 12 Monkeys a lot lately. It seems, these days, as though the human race has passed a Rubicon and is now on a straight path toward the end of days, or at least the end of the social order as we know it." - the OP.

"[I]sn’t it obvious that chicken little represents the sane vision? And that homo sapiens’s motto, ‘Let’s go shopping,’ is the cry of the true lunatic?” - the mass murdering virologist.

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#3
If you have not seen it, highly recommend the original film this was based on, La Jette as mentioned in the article. It is a (shortish) masterpiece of French SciFi, all in black and white, shot almost entirely in still scenes, and fully narrated.

And i would argue it does follow fairly closely in terms of script and meaning to the remake than the article suggests. It is much more subtle and nuanced.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_Jet%C3%A9e

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#4
post #3

If you have not seen it, highly recommend the original film this was based on, La Jette as mentioned in the article. It is a (shortish) masterpiece of French SciFi, all in black and white, shot almost entirely in still scenes, and fully narrated. And i would argue it does follow fairly closely in terms of script and meaning to the remake than the article suggests. It is much more subtle and nuanced. https://en.wikipe…

La Jette reminds me of another under appreciated french movie Le Dernier Combat. Double first for Luc Besson and Jean Reno.

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#5
post #3

If you have not seen it, highly recommend the original film this was based on, La Jette as mentioned in the article. It is a (shortish) masterpiece of French SciFi, all in black and white, shot almost entirely in still scenes, and fully narrated. And i would argue it does follow fairly closely in terms of script and meaning to the remake than the article suggests. It is much more subtle and nuanced. https://en.wikipe…

La Jetée

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#6

The catastrophe in 12 Monkeys is due to the action of a single individual - an ideologue concerned with the "biosphere". The pathology highlighted is ideological thought that justifies mass murder. Love certainly conquers all in this film. It is precisely love (here romantic love) that weaves an unalterable thread through time and binds the two individuals who are absolutely necessary for the future salvation of mank…

I've rewatched the movie recently. Humanity is definitly not saved. The whole quest is shown as being nothing a but a futile yet beautiful slice of life. It's espacially underlined with the scene revealing the origin of the voice mail that was supposedly the only clue of the whole shebang for the future scientists.

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#7
While I loved 12 Monkeys story & most of TG's body of work, I must posit "Brazil" is more relevant in our non-fiction world than anything else he has done. I hesitate to note the multitude of similarities to our current state of information retrieval & bureaucracies. Zero Theorem seemed to touch the needle but sorta fizzled out mid-way(IMO).

Yes, I did not RTFA.

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#8
"the ’90s, that bizarre blip in American history where it seemed like we were living in an eternal present, the End of History"

That's something millennials & later won't understand: 2000 was a mental barrier we couldn't really think past. Objectively, people may have addressed the next millennium's dates, but we just couldn't deeply believe we'd be living in what was always colloquially called "the future".

Re: ‘12 Monkeys’: Why Terry Gilliam’s Movie Is Relevant Today

#10
post #3

If you have not seen it, highly recommend the original film this was based on, La Jette as mentioned in the article. It is a (shortish) masterpiece of French SciFi, all in black and white, shot almost entirely in still scenes, and fully narrated. And i would argue it does follow fairly closely in terms of script and meaning to the remake than the article suggests. It is much more subtle and nuanced. https://en.wikipe…

Thank you for this. It is on youtube and absolutely amazing.
Post reply on HN