Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
1–10 of 24 posts
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#2A little too ambitious.
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#3This would be a useful service if their system could detect signs of skin cancer.
In terms of squelching revenge porn, I do not see how this would remove anything from non facebook servers. Is 4chan going to integrate with this? Are they really only using hashing? Simple hash checks are negated with trivial effort.
If they are just hashes, why are users uploading anything beyond a hash? Example: virustotal [0] can get the hash of a file using javascript rather than uploading the file. Is this to see that the file is really porn?
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#4I wonder what's their real agenda with these photos. You can never take what Facebook says at face value. Just like when they say they're only building shadow profiles on you for security purposes.
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#5Will the hash take into account that some body parts may change shape compared to the sample photo Facebook asks us ?
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#6This would be a useful service if their system could detect signs of skin cancer. In terms of squelching revenge porn, I do not see how this would remove anything from non facebook servers. Is 4chan going to integrate with this? Are they really only using hashing? Simple hash checks are negated with trivial effort. If they are just hashes, why are users uploading anything beyond a hash? Example: virustotal [0] can ge…
It's not just hashes of the raw bytes of the photos. More likely something like PhotoDNA[1] that's already used for tracking child porn.
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#7Discussion from 7 months ago (over 50 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15648080
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#8This would be a useful service if their system could detect signs of skin cancer. In terms of squelching revenge porn, I do not see how this would remove anything from non facebook servers. Is 4chan going to integrate with this? Are they really only using hashing? Simple hash checks are negated with trivial effort. If they are just hashes, why are users uploading anything beyond a hash? Example: virustotal [0] can ge…
I doubt it is Simple file level Hashing
MS Pioneered tech for Child Porn that looks at the actual photo and hashes parts of the file, PhotoID, that makes is more robot than a simple file hash, which ML I am sure this has improved alot in the decades it was first released
However I agree that is unlikely to curb Revenge Porn...
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#9I wonder what's their real agenda with these photos. You can never take what Facebook says at face value. Just like when they say they're only building shadow profiles on you for security purposes.
There is already plenty of porn on the internet, why do they need more?
Re: Facebook wants your naked photos to stop revenge porn
#10I wonder what's their real agenda with these photos. You can never take what Facebook says at face value. Just like when they say they're only building shadow profiles on you for security purposes.
For all its flaws, I don't think that it's likely that FB would move into the blackmail space.