Live data from Hacker News

The Very Last Thing I’ll Write About Twitter

al3x.net

1–10 of 31 posts

Re: The Very Last Thing I’ll Write About Twitter

#2
Nail on head for me:

". . . Twitter Platform primarily serves Twitter’s interests, in stark contrast to the era of API growth . . ."

and his rueful close in "I believe that Twitter as a medium is and should be distinct from Twitter as a business."

Twitter got to where they are based on open standards, dev empowerment, etc.

Thanks to their money in the bank and lack of need for a biz model they had ample time to own it, be the standard, become the medium - what is a Twitter exactly if not a Twitter?

Going to be very interesting to see where this next step takes them.

Re: The Very Last Thing I’ll Write About Twitter

#5
His comments on the difference between Twitter and Facebook are particularly interesting:

"Previously, developers took data out of Twitter and into the context of their own applications and services. The new design flips this on its head, bringing rich embedded content into the site from a host of brand-name web properties. (It’s worth noting that Facebook has done much the opposite: they started out with a very centralized build-it-within-our-walls model, then gradually grew their tendrils out into the web with Facebook Connect.)"

I'm curious how this relates to his later observation that "walled gardens" are doomed to fail. In both instances, the walls are being chipped away, but in the former, the content is being brought in, while in the latter, content is being let out.

Re: The Very Last Thing I’ll Write About Twitter

#8
post #5

His comments on the difference between Twitter and Facebook are particularly interesting: "Previously, developers took data out of Twitter and into the context of their own applications and services. The new design flips this on its head, bringing rich embedded content into the site from a host of brand-name web properties. (It’s worth noting that Facebook has done much the opposite: they started out with a very cent…

[deleted]

Re: The Very Last Thing I’ll Write About Twitter

#9
Well worth reading the whole thing. It’s not too long, and he’s already Readability’d it for us, if you will.

But if you don’t have time:

• #NewTwitter will make Twitter more mainstream, and will provide advertisement opportunities.

• #NewTwitter is a shift away from being a platform towards being a destination (or “place of consumption,” if you will), and as such further complicates relationships with third-party developers.

• Twitter should become decentralized, but it’s clearly in Twitter’s best interested not to.

• Alex circulated a document internally advocating decentralization, and executives disagreed (understandably).

Post reply on HN