Live data from Hacker News

This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

blog.digit.co

1–10 of 30 posts

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#2
"The technology to make AI-powered assistants truly useful is still far out of reach, and people aren't rushing to close that gap by adapting their behavior."

Exactly; if you build a bot with the intention of relying 100% on NLP, you're asking for trouble. But I fail to see how that fact leads to chatbots being useless when there are plenty of tools available for guiding necessary optimizations that can lead to a much better experience.

When websites were bad we turned to tools like Google Analytics to make website development data driven -- we didn't stop building them.

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#3

"The technology to make AI-powered assistants truly useful is still far out of reach, and people aren't rushing to close that gap by adapting their behavior." Exactly; if you build a bot with the intention of relying 100% on NLP, you're asking for trouble. But I fail to see how that fact leads to chatbots being useless when there are plenty of tools available for guiding necessary optimizations that can lead to a muc…

To be fair, regular people use websites. Regular people do not use chatbots in significant numbers

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#4

"The technology to make AI-powered assistants truly useful is still far out of reach, and people aren't rushing to close that gap by adapting their behavior." Exactly; if you build a bot with the intention of relying 100% on NLP, you're asking for trouble. But I fail to see how that fact leads to chatbots being useless when there are plenty of tools available for guiding necessary optimizations that can lead to a muc…

To be fair, regular people use websites. Regular people do not use chatbots in significant numbers

I don't disagree but how is that relevant?

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#6
I've thought for some time now that the real killer app for natural language assistants—especially voice activated assistants like Alexa, perhaps slightly less suited for text-based chatbots—lies in short, episodic, choose-your-own-adventure-style games. The more I think about it, the more I'm not really sure why this isn't a thing yet, and why we haven't seen a resurgence in the popularity of interactive fiction—albeit this time for the masses, and not necessarily limited to those inclined to go load up a copy of Zork.

And content creation is more accessible than ever. I mean, have you seen an example of what the source code for an Inform7 game looks like?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inform#Inform_7_programming_la...

To reiterate, it almost seems crazy that there isn't a massive catalog of $0.99 serials that you can play through in 45-minute chapters while cooking, driving down the road with the family or on the way to work, etc.

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#7
Dear people who have product blogs like this: Please put a global header on your blog that says "X is a Y that does Z." In this case, "Digit is a service that helps you automatically save money based on your income and spending." That way, we get some much-needed context when we stumble across your blog articles talking about what you've learned by building and selling your product.

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#8

I've thought for some time now that the real killer app for natural language assistants—especially voice activated assistants like Alexa, perhaps slightly less suited for text-based chatbots—lies in short, episodic, choose-your-own-adventure-style games. The more I think about it, the more I'm not really sure why this isn't a thing yet, and why we haven't seen a resurgence in the popularity of interactive fiction—alb…

I've often thought the same. Zork is the path to a conversational bot that people find it worthwhile to talk to.

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#9

I've thought for some time now that the real killer app for natural language assistants—especially voice activated assistants like Alexa, perhaps slightly less suited for text-based chatbots—lies in short, episodic, choose-your-own-adventure-style games. The more I think about it, the more I'm not really sure why this isn't a thing yet, and why we haven't seen a resurgence in the popularity of interactive fiction—alb…

Oh man. I've had 0 interest in any of the voice activated assistants so far. But this would be the killer app that would get me on board.

Re: This Conversation Is Going Nowhere

#10

I've thought for some time now that the real killer app for natural language assistants—especially voice activated assistants like Alexa, perhaps slightly less suited for text-based chatbots—lies in short, episodic, choose-your-own-adventure-style games. The more I think about it, the more I'm not really sure why this isn't a thing yet, and why we haven't seen a resurgence in the popularity of interactive fiction—alb…

This is such a great idea.

Apparently some exist:

https://www.polygon.com/features/2017/2/27/14643756/text-adv...

Post reply on HN