Live data from Hacker News

Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

rtalbert.org

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#2
Quick, what goes in the blank?

    The free access which many young people have to *BLANK* has poisoned the mind and
    corrupted the morals of many a promising youth; and prevented others from improving
    their minds in useful knowledge. Parents take care to feed their children with
    wholesome diet; and yet how unconcerned about the provision for the mind, whether
    they are furnished with salutary food, or with trash, chaff, or poison?
Trick question, it's not "screens". It's "romances, novels, and plays" - quote taken from "Memoirs of the Bloomsgrove Family", Reverend Enos Hitchcock, 1790.

I'm all for carefully considering which tools you use every day, but spare me the moralizing - it was gauche in 1790 and it hasn't improved with age.

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#4
My issue here is that screen content today often of very low quality.

It's even worse than TV was 25 years ago (actual TV became worse too during that period).

Even what I'm having on my screen, non-work-related, is information equivalent of trash food.

I now have doubts whether I am comfortable in letting my kid on this crapfest. Case in point: games that have no gameplay, no difficulty, no plot, no information, and exist solely to make spend money via in-app purchases. This of course lets them kill off everything else on market by putting half of that money into advertising.

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#6
I have to agree with what others here have said: the moralizing rubs me the wrong way and, in this case, I don't think it serves any purpose but to move blame away from the author and onto the technology that he perceives as his primary problem.

I have a child and they have access to a Kindle, our television (with Netflix, Amazon Prime, etc.) as well as our Nintendo 3DS. These all (in my opinion) serve much the same purpose: entertain, distract and in some circumstances help people relax. Since the beginning my partner and I have been clear that it's not okay to sit in front of one (or cycle through them all) for hours at a time. At this point our child is seven and they rarely exceed more than 30 minutes at a time of screen interaction. For the most part, they move onto something else on their own.

Clearly part of it is personality, but I do think some part was the establishment of clear boundaries from the start. Perhaps when my child hits the teen years, I'll have to revisit this battle but for now keeping screen time at a minimum is a fairly low friction activity.

As this author demonstrates, there's a very real challenge as parents to make the time to schedule activities or to encourage children to get out and play. This strikes me as eternal problems: no seven year old is great at planning ahead or has the ability to schedule their own play dates. But, unlike when I was a child, there are more options than staring at a blank wall or digging deep holes in the backyard.

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#7
post #4

My issue here is that screen content today often of very low quality. It's even worse than TV was 25 years ago (actual TV became worse too during that period). Even what I'm having on my screen, non-work-related, is information equivalent of trash food. I now have doubts whether I am comfortable in letting my kid on this crapfest. Case in point: games that have no gameplay, no difficulty, no plot, no information, and…

I agree that there's a lot of crap out there, but I'm not entirely sure that the crap to not-crap ratio is larger than it has always been. I remember saving up dimes and quarters to buy discounted Atari 2600 cartridges only to find re-hashed versions of games that I already had played. Television, in particular, I remember as being pretty terrible and repetitive. That it's so much easier to get at the stuff, that seems like the biggest change to me.

Children aren't particularly great at ferreting out the best content, but I think that when they work together with parents (or older siblings, etc.) that are at least somewhat interested then they can find some real gems. The Toca Boca games (so far) have lacked in-app purchases and can be a lot of fun. There's some really good content out on Amazon and Netflix, I find that if I spend a little time working with my child every so often, we find some really fun stuff.

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#8
post #4

My issue here is that screen content today often of very low quality. It's even worse than TV was 25 years ago (actual TV became worse too during that period). Even what I'm having on my screen, non-work-related, is information equivalent of trash food. I now have doubts whether I am comfortable in letting my kid on this crapfest. Case in point: games that have no gameplay, no difficulty, no plot, no information, and…

There's still plenty of really excellent tv and games out there, there's just also a lot more crap too.

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#9
post #6

I have to agree with what others here have said: the moralizing rubs me the wrong way and, in this case, I don't think it serves any purpose but to move blame away from the author and onto the technology that he perceives as his primary problem. I have a child and they have access to a Kindle, our television (with Netflix, Amazon Prime, etc.) as well as our Nintendo 3DS. These all (in my opinion) serve much the same…

> Clearly part of it is personality, but I do think some part was the establishment of clear boundaries from the start. Perhaps when my child hits the teen years, I'll have to revisit this battle but for now keeping screen time at a minimum is a fairly low friction activity.

I think this is absolutely key. I see screens like I see sugary foods. Not inherently bad for kids, but best consumed in moderation AND something that kids will over-consume if left to their own devices.

Re: Returning to analog and putting digital in its place

#10
post #5
post #3

Based on title I first assumed that this is about signal processing, but then came the disappointment.

I thought it was about analog computing like [1] but sadly not... [1] https://blog.degruyter.com/algorithms-suck-analog-computers-...

Yeah, that's what I was expecting as well.
Post reply on HN