Live data from Hacker News

First detection of the missing half of normal matter in our universe

newscientist.com

1–10 of 131 posts

Re: First detection of the missing half of normal matter in our universe

#2
https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/75944s/half_the_univ...

> The approximate distribution in the Universe is 5% regular matter, 25% Dark Matter, and 70% Dark Energy. Half of that 5% was missing, and now found.

> Regular matter makes stars and visible galaxies, so it is "bright". Dark Matter is so named because it does not make things we can see with telescopes directly - it is "dark". We can see the effects it makes with gravity, such as the rotation curves of galaxies, and gravitational lensing. So we know something is there, just not what it is made of. Dark Energy was invented to solve a couple of mysteries. One is the geometrical "flatness" of the Universe, and the other is the apparent acceleration of the Universe's expansion. Like Dark Matter, we don't yet know what it is. But something is causing the flatness and acceleration, so we gave it a name as a place-holder for theories.

> A similar situation happened a century ago, with the precession (shift) of Mercury's orbit with time. We thought it was caused by a planet inside of Mercury's orbit that we hadn't found yet. It was named Vulcan, after the Roman god of fire (not Spock's home planet). It turns out relativity was the right answer - the Suns gravity bends space near it, and causes the orbit to shift. Vulcan was just "a name we gave to whatever causes the observed effect".

> Dark Matter and Dark Energy could turn out to be something entirely different than types of matter and energy, but in the mean time it gives them names we can attach theories about them to.

Re: First detection of the missing half of normal matter in our universe

#3

https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/75944s/half_the_univ... > The approximate distribution in the Universe is 5% regular matter, 25% Dark Matter, and 70% Dark Energy. Half of that 5% was missing, and now found. > Regular matter makes stars and visible galaxies, so it is "bright". Dark Matter is so named because it does not make things we can see with telescopes directly - it is "dark". We can see the effects it m…

"...it gives them names we can attach theories about them to." Sometimes I think this gets lost in conversations about scientific topics. It's easy to be flippant about what we know in relation to scientists of the past, and miss out on an appropriate sense of awe about how much in the universe there is to discover.

Re: First detection of the missing half of normal matter in our universe

#4

https://www.reddit.com/r/space/comments/75944s/half_the_univ... > The approximate distribution in the Universe is 5% regular matter, 25% Dark Matter, and 70% Dark Energy. Half of that 5% was missing, and now found. > Regular matter makes stars and visible galaxies, so it is "bright". Dark Matter is so named because it does not make things we can see with telescopes directly - it is "dark". We can see the effects it m…

Thank you! 2.5% of the universe's missing matter has been found.

Re: First detection of the missing half of normal matter in our universe

#6
> Half the universe’s missing matter has just been finally found

The first paragraph clarifies that this headline means "The missing (regular) matter comprising half the (regular matter in the) Universe has been finally found" rather than "Half of the missing (regular) matter in the Universe has just been found (and where could the other half be?)".

Re: First detection of the missing half of normal matter in our universe

#9
Can I just check - my understanding is that we can only see 5% of the expected mass in the universe - so we have just found another 5%? meaning dark matter needs to account for 90%?

plus, how awesomely beautiful is the idea of tendrils of has connecting the galaxies through space.

Post reply on HN