Live data from Hacker News

Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

sagi.io

1–10 of 46 posts

Re: Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

#3
post #2

Every month or so there is a new version of an article like this posted on hn

At this point I believe these articles are the result of people who got over their own confusion/misunderstanding by writing a new article on bloom filters. Eventually there will be a 1:1 ratio of bloom filter articles / developers.

Re: Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

#4
post #2

Every month or so there is a new version of an article like this posted on hn

At this point I believe these articles are the result of people who got over their own confusion/misunderstanding by writing a new article on bloom filters. Eventually there will be a 1:1 ratio of bloom filter articles / developers.

So, bloom filters are the equivalent of Monads? https://byorgey.wordpress.com/2009/01/12/abstraction-intuiti...

Re: Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

#6
post #2

Every month or so there is a new version of an article like this posted on hn

I read a few of these articles a couple of years ago. Along with a few of the inevitable cuckoo hash filter rejoinders.

I think they are neat algorithms and I'm glad to have come across them. But that said, I have yet to find a problem in my day to day work which required set membership, with space at a premium, and where false positives were acceptable. So I've never used either in anger.

Re: Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

#7
post #2

Every month or so there is a new version of an article like this posted on hn

I read a few of these articles a couple of years ago. Along with a few of the inevitable cuckoo hash filter rejoinders. I think they are neat algorithms and I'm glad to have come across them. But that said, I have yet to find a problem in my day to day work which required set membership, with space at a premium, and where false positives were acceptable. So I've never used either in anger.

They're very useful in large scale web crawling/scraping. I use them for a number of things in this field.

Re: Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

#9
post #8

When I first heard of Bloom filters, I thought of the Bloom effect - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom_(shader_effect) - and we used to call these things filters for a while - then friend of mine told me about the other meaning :)

I'm also always having to perform the manual translation in my head from shader effect when I read this term.

Re: Bloom Filters for the Perplexed

#10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At this point I believe these articles are the result of people who got over their own confusion/misunderstanding by writing a new article on bloom filters. Eventually there will be a 1:1 ratio of bloom filter articles / developers.

So, bloom filters are the equivalent of Monads? https://byorgey.wordpress.com/2009/01/12/abstraction-intuiti...

They both seem like fairly easy concepts. I'm not sure why they get so much coverage.
Post reply on HN