Live data from Hacker News

Parasites may explain regional differences in intelligence

economist.com

1–10 of 35 posts

Re: Parasites may explain regional differences in intelligence

#7
post #2

I'm really curious as to how exactly they accounted for other factors. They say they compared findings to other studies that looked at other possible explanations, but quite many of them are certainly correlated if not caused by one another.

one can deduce how two kinds of organisms have influenced each other by studying how their respective gene pools (have) co-evolve(d)

Re: Parasites may explain regional differences in intelligence

#8
post #6

Correlation causation. IMHO they should be very careful before establishing a link between those two.

You should read the article. They considered that.

The correlation is about 67%, and the chance that it might have come about at random is less than one in 10,000. But correlation is not causation, so Mr Eppig and his colleagues tried to eliminate other possible explanations. Previous work has offered income, education, low levels of agricultural labour (which is replaced by more mentally stimulating jobs), climate (the challenge of surviving cold weather might provoke the evolution of intelligence) and even distance from humanity’s African homeland (novel environments could encourage greater intelligence) as explanations for national differences in IQ. However, all of these, except perhaps the last, are also likely to be linked to disease and, by careful statistical analysis, Mr Eppig and his colleagues show that all of them either disappear or are reduced to a small effect when the consequences of disease are taken into account.

There is, moreover, direct evidence that infections and parasites affect cognition. Intestinal worms have been shown to do so on many occasions. Malaria, too, is bad for the brain. A study of children in Kenya who survived the cerebral version of the disease suggests that an eighth of them suffer long-term cognitive damage. In the view of Mr Eppig and his colleagues, however, it is the various bugs that cause diarrhoea which are the biggest threat. Diarrhoea strikes children hard. It accounts for a sixth of infant deaths, and even in those it does not kill it prevents the absorption of food at a time when the brain is growing and developing rapidly.

Re: Parasites may explain regional differences in intelligence

#9
post #4

My first thought: which parasites make you smarter?

Had the same thought, though the article says that the lack of infectious disease (parasites) would cause intelligence gain. The population of countries where disease is less of a problem wouldn't see the same benefit...
Post reply on HN