Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
lowtechmagazine.com
Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
1–10 of 19 posts
Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#2This is basically an art project. Even a basic thought process shows how ridiculous this is: If you're going to use humans just as basic energy input, why not just burn the food directly and use that?
Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#3Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#4> Unlike fossil fuels, human power can be a clean energy source, and its potential increases as the human population grows.
It's the opposite: Human power cannot feed the 7.5 billion people and growing. You need ammonia and (right now) oil, and lots of it. When we "scaled up" humanity, we left human power long behind as an option for any but a few hundred million. Just the food part alone is impossible.
They then segue into a different question: "if human power can sustain a modern lifestyle", but even then they don't mean modern food requirements, they really just mean "can humans keep the lights on in the one building they are in."
> A human powered student community has enormous potential for a reduction in energy use.
This is a complete misunderstanding of just how much energy gets the people in the Netherlands their... say avocados. Thinking of your energy consumption as lights in your building is so very off.
I recently wrote a counter-point essay to the headline's topic, how technology is now a moral necessity just to keep humanity treading water, and how oil set off a Malthusian time-bomb.
Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#5Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#6The answer to the headline is an emphatic "No." > Unlike fossil fuels, human power can be a clean energy source, and its potential increases as the human population grows. It's the opposite: Human power cannot feed the 7.5 billion people and growing. You need ammonia and (right now) oil, and lots of it. When we "scaled up" humanity, we left human power long behind as an option for any but a few hundred million. Just…
Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#7Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#8Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#9The answer to the headline is an emphatic "No." > Unlike fossil fuels, human power can be a clean energy source, and its potential increases as the human population grows. It's the opposite: Human power cannot feed the 7.5 billion people and growing. You need ammonia and (right now) oil, and lots of it. When we "scaled up" humanity, we left human power long behind as an option for any but a few hundred million. Just…
Re: Could We Run Modern Society on Human Power Alone?
#1060W is 60J per second. 60J is about the energy it takes to weigh 6kg up one meter.
So basically to keep a 60W light bulb lit, you'd have to raise 6kg one meter high every single second.
No way.