Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 35 posts

Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#1
Since the discussion for PG's ycombinator.com/ideas.html seems to have gone stale (and possibly out-dated) lets get a new discussion going.

There are also a lot of "What do you want built.." posts, so lets consolidate.

Answer any of the following questions:

1) What needs in your life do you wish were fulfilled online?

2) What online sites do you admire and how could you see a similar concept working in lateral industries?

3) What offline sectors do you see as the least represented online?

4) And then to go back to the original ycombinator.com/ideas.htm - feel free to elaborate or add to the list. (in the same vein, generally speaking)

Re: Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#3
1/3) Auto repair / servicing. The internet has helped consumers in all kinds of markets - retail and travel, perhaps most obviously - compare equivalent goods to ensure they are getting a fair price and good service. I would love for this to be applied to car repair and servicing. I confess that I know next to nothing about cars - I just want my car to run, and when it need repairs or services, I want to know that I'm getting a fair price. As it stands I have no idea really.

There are two aspects to this problem: (i) the garage is both doctor and pharmacist - there is an incentive to take advantage of my lack of knowledge and propose unnecessary work; and (ii) I don't know whether, for the services and goods proposed as necessary (including labour), the price is fair.

I know this is stuff that I should probably know, but I feel like there is an opportunity for this all to be made better.

Re: Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#4
post #3

1/3) Auto repair / servicing. The internet has helped consumers in all kinds of markets - retail and travel, perhaps most obviously - compare equivalent goods to ensure they are getting a fair price and good service. I would love for this to be applied to car repair and servicing. I confess that I know next to nothing about cars - I just want my car to run, and when it need repairs or services, I want to know that I'…

That would be cool. Is anybody doing that now?

Initially "incentivize" people to submit year/make/model, then repair/parts/labor and build up a database of prices (later users would do the same thing with estimates).

I believe labor rates are the same across repairs so you could split that out as the dealer's standard rate. Add service reviews, etc.

Re: Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#5
post #3

1/3) Auto repair / servicing. The internet has helped consumers in all kinds of markets - retail and travel, perhaps most obviously - compare equivalent goods to ensure they are getting a fair price and good service. I would love for this to be applied to car repair and servicing. I confess that I know next to nothing about cars - I just want my car to run, and when it need repairs or services, I want to know that I'…

http://repairpal.com

Techcrunch about them: http://techcrunch.com/2008/06/12/repairpal-its-like-google-h...

Re: Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#6
post #5
post #3

1/3) Auto repair / servicing. The internet has helped consumers in all kinds of markets - retail and travel, perhaps most obviously - compare equivalent goods to ensure they are getting a fair price and good service. I would love for this to be applied to car repair and servicing. I confess that I know next to nothing about cars - I just want my car to run, and when it need repairs or services, I want to know that I'…

http://repairpal.com Techcrunch about them: http://techcrunch.com/2008/06/12/repairpal-its-like-google-h...

Here's the HN thread about them from about a year ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=755665

Re: Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#7
I have personally loved sites which have tried to utilize the "intelligence of masses" and wikipedia being the prime example of that. Similarly Hacker News, Reddit, StackOverflow and many others which excite me the most.

1) I think I'd love a much better way of finding homes/real-estate which can derive synergy from 3rd-party apps like Google Maps as well as bring about some kind of social features more in the line of commenting we see on HN.

2) Mentioned earlier.

3) I think one can see huge opportunities in B2B niches. There seems to be a great unfilled opportunity in bringing together the businesses. The thing is that most of these businesses don't understand anything about web or Google Adwords which they might use to better market their products. The idea is to make it extremely simple for them to find other businesses which might be willing to buy the products and services.

Re: Ask HN: Let's Revive PG's /ideas.html discussion

#9
post #7

I have personally loved sites which have tried to utilize the "intelligence of masses" and wikipedia being the prime example of that. Similarly Hacker News, Reddit, StackOverflow and many others which excite me the most. 1) I think I'd love a much better way of finding homes/real-estate which can derive synergy from 3rd-party apps like Google Maps as well as bring about some kind of social features more in the line o…

I've been consulting (as a software developer) for a large home-building company for a while now and this experience has given me quite a few ideas and insight related to your #1. I'd be curious to hear you elaborate on this a bit more. Billions and billions of dollars go through this industry every year (even when it's down) and yet, the industry as a whole doesn't understand the web. So there are plenty of opportunities.
Post reply on HN