Live data from Hacker News

Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

shift.newco.co

1–10 of 71 posts

Re: Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

#3
I'm not sure what to make out of such a text.

Basically what the text says is that plant-based food usually is less resource intense and thus better for the environment, but there are also other factors and plant-based food production isn't perfect. (Independent of the question whether all the other things he says are true.)

So the headline is obviously strictly true, but highly misleading. A more accurate one would be "Vegetarian diets are good for the planet, but they're not the whole solution".

Re: Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

#4
>Most of these staple crops — especially corn and soy — wind up in animal feed and fuel;

Exactly. So why should eating less of the same food than is necessary to produce a substantially smaller amount of meat be discouraged? Using less resources overall is still better, right?

edit: formatting

Re: Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

#5

The article should be titled something more like 'Local, Seasonal Diets Are Going To Save The Planet'. It's not much about vegetarianism, except to attack it for clickbait reasons.

And a local, seasonal vegetarian diet is a lot easier to implement in a city environment than a local, seasonal omnivorous diet. So vegetarian is still likely to be a better option in the future, especially if you consider vat-grown meat to be a vegetable.

Re: Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

#7
Most of the arguments are just an appeal to nature. Doesn't address cow burps as a major source of pollution. Seems to be making a food miles argument, when what matters is carbon per pound of food. Transporting by boat is highly efficient and a high percentage of the cargo is food. Driving to pick up your food from 3 farmer's markets can create more pollution than would be used to transport them from across the world, because the food is such a small percentage of the weight of your car.

Re: Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

#8
> Unfortunately, most food plants in this country are grown in resource-intensive systems that groan under the weight of a relentlessly demanding global consumer,

Question: aren't 'local', small-scale farms more resource-intensive per unit of food grown than factory farms, not less?

Re: Vegetarian diets are not going to save the planet

#10
The author should cite the article(s) that claim vegetarian diets alone will save the planet - this is clickbait/trolling. I'm a vegetarian and make no claim that being so is going to save the planet - it would help if we all were but it's definitely not a silver bullet.
Post reply on HN