Ask HN: Should I comment in HN or on individual blogs?

#1

Post by wrjk » Mon, Mar 29, 2010, 5:14 PM UTC

I'm new to HN and I see some posts (which link to blog entries) have quite a bit of commenting and discussion going on here while others don't. Is there etiquette involved in discussing here vs. discussing directly on the linked blog.

Insightful discussion is valuable to a blogger's community but is HN-only discussion more valuable here?

Re: Ask HN: Should I comment in HN or on individual blogs?

#2

Post by icey » Mon, Mar 29, 2010, 5:15 PM UTC

I almost always comment on HN because I like the people here. Some people post on both the blog and here. Some people just post on the blog.

It's really up to you; I don't think there's anything wrong with posting in both places if you want.

Re: Ask HN: Should I comment in HN or on individual blogs?

#3

Post by vijaydev » Mon, Mar 29, 2010, 5:34 PM UTC

if your comments can lead to insightful discussions, why not both? Doing in HN is more fun because more people tend to respond to your point

Re: Ask HN: Should I comment in HN or on individual blogs?

#4

Post by duck » Mon, Mar 29, 2010, 6:10 PM UTC

icey wrote: post #2

I almost always comment on HN because I like the people here. Some people post on both the blog and here. Some people just post on the blog. It's really up to you; I don't think there's anything wrong with posting in both places if you want.

I agree, but I tend to read HN comments a lot more b/c of the way they get sorted by votes and in general they seem more insightful to me. If the author of the blog isn't on HN, then I am probably more likely to comment on their blog as well.

Re: Ask HN: Should I comment in HN or on individual blogs?

#5

Post by ScottWhigham » Mon, Mar 29, 2010, 6:16 PM UTC

It depends on who I want to have a discussion with. If the original poster (OP) is the blog author, then I'm probably going to comment in whichever environment I think I can talk with the author. If the OP is not the author and I want to talk to the author, then I'd comment on the blog. If I want to rant/rave but not really to the author specifically, then to HN.

But that's me - do what you want.

Re: Ask HN: Should I comment in HN or on individual blogs?

#6

Post by pedalpete » Mon, Mar 29, 2010, 6:21 PM UTC

I rarely find myself commenting on the blogs for two reasons

1) I don't want to have to fill out all the info they request (unless it is a blog I regularly find myself going to

2) I don't want to have to remember to go back to the blog to see further discussion and comments.

HN just makes it so easy to go back and see the threads that I found interesting and I can then read what other HNers have said.