Live data from Hacker News

Passive TCP/IP Geo-Location

geoloc.foremski.pl

1–10 of 91 posts

Re: Passive TCP/IP Geo-Location

#2
> This website demonstrates IP address geo-location by passively measuring TCP/IP round-trip times of web requests made to a few servers spread around the world.

I don't get how that could be called passive. This is making your browser issue requests or am I missing something?

Re: Passive TCP/IP Geo-Location

#3
post #2

> This website demonstrates IP address geo-location by passively measuring TCP/IP round-trip times of web requests made to a few servers spread around the world. I don't get how that could be called passive. This is making your browser issue requests or am I missing something?

I believe the author's point was you could determine the location by monitoring other applications and their network calls.

That being said, I highly doubt there are many requests being made to Bangalore, India and this appears to require requests to a wide array of locations all over the world.

Re: Passive TCP/IP Geo-Location

#4
post #2

> This website demonstrates IP address geo-location by passively measuring TCP/IP round-trip times of web requests made to a few servers spread around the world. I don't get how that could be called passive. This is making your browser issue requests or am I missing something?

Not passive at all, as it loads content from different sources. Plus the circles are all over the place without any logic.

Re: Passive TCP/IP Geo-Location

#5
post #2

> This website demonstrates IP address geo-location by passively measuring TCP/IP round-trip times of web requests made to a few servers spread around the world. I don't get how that could be called passive. This is making your browser issue requests or am I missing something?

I agree passive is a bit odd phrasing. Though, with how many 3rd party assets websites load nowadays, I suspect this could be done without introducing any additional requests by passively monitoring the already-existing 3rd party requests.

Re: Passive TCP/IP Geo-Location

#9
post #2

> This website demonstrates IP address geo-location by passively measuring TCP/IP round-trip times of web requests made to a few servers spread around the world. I don't get how that could be called passive. This is making your browser issue requests or am I missing something?

I think the author means passive in a way that no known geoip DB is used.
Post reply on HN