Live data from Hacker News

Sunspring, a short science fiction film written by algorithm

arstechnica.com

1–10 of 50 posts

Re: Sunspring, a short science fiction film written by algorithm

#3
post #2

Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters; makes me wonder how it would do at producing stories without any characters; such stories exist, bit SciFi feeling too.

Meaningful? It sounded like some one tried to physically act out a clever bot self-conversation. ( http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vphmJEpLXU0 )

This is a great example of how far we are from artificial intelligence. The actors/directors/etc did a great job of trying to make it work.

I like what they tried to do to make it coherent, but it just goes to show that there is no way to save truly bad incoherent writing.

Re: Sunspring, a short science fiction film written by algorithm

#4
post #2

Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters; makes me wonder how it would do at producing stories without any characters; such stories exist, bit SciFi feeling too.

> Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters

Does it? I think the actors and film makers did a pretty good job of creating a film with meaning and characters, despite not having much to work with. In fact a lot of the fun of this is watching the actors try to make something out of the word salad they've been given.

Edit: If you want to see the script unembellished by the cast and crew it's here https://www.docdroid.net/lCZ2fPA/sunspring-final.pdf.html

It's a damn thing scared to say. Nothing is going to be a thing.

Re: Sunspring, a short science fiction film written by algorithm

#6
post #2

Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters; makes me wonder how it would do at producing stories without any characters; such stories exist, bit SciFi feeling too.

A whole line of narrative theory would say that the sequential action matters more than any character development. That goes against a lot creative writing class assumptions, but those classes might be wrong.

Re: Sunspring, a short science fiction film written by algorithm

#7
post #2

Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters; makes me wonder how it would do at producing stories without any characters; such stories exist, bit SciFi feeling too.

A whole line of narrative theory would say that the sequential action matters more than any character development. That goes against a lot creative writing class assumptions, but those classes might be wrong.

Where can I read more about this line of narrative theory?

Edit: nm, googling.

Re: Sunspring, a short science fiction film written by algorithm

#9
post #4
post #2

Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters; makes me wonder how it would do at producing stories without any characters; such stories exist, bit SciFi feeling too.

> Interesting that the AI is able to produce a meaningful storyline without fully understanding characters Does it? I think the actors and film makers did a pretty good job of creating a film with meaning and characters, despite not having much to work with. In fact a lot of the fun of this is watching the actors try to make something out of the word salad they've been given. Edit: If you want to see the script unemb…

Also we fill in tons of subtext I'm quite sure the AI has no idea about.
Post reply on HN