Live data from Hacker News

FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

techdirt.com

1–10 of 129 posts

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#2
The worst thing about this is that it will turn out that the developers involvement will be relatively innocuous in the grand scheme of things, hence the lack of any real urgency from the FBI, but it is terrifying for both the developer and as a citizen that he FBI seem to be inept and/or deliberately making it so difficult to speak with someone who it would appear they think can assist them.

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#5
It sounds like her concern is that they might show her a magic piece of paper which, once you've seen it, requires you to do certain things and prohibits you from ever talking about it to anyone.[1]

Magic pieces of paper like that really shouldn't be a part of our legal system.

[1] https://epic.org/privacy/nsl/

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#6
The original story told about a couple of polite phonecalls where they have requested to talk with her. How does it get described as "harassment"? Of course, she also added a lot of paranoid speculation to her original blog post, but there's not a single confirmation of her fears so far, not even a hint.

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#7
post #6

The original story told about a couple of polite phonecalls where they have requested to talk with her. How does it get described as "harassment"? Of course, she also added a lot of paranoid speculation to her original blog post, but there's not a single confirmation of her fears so far, not even a hint.

>The original story told about a couple of polite phonecalls where they have requested to talk with her. How does it get described as "harassment"?

As soon as they continued after the very first 'no' it becomes harassment. Imagine this was a work setting, the FBI was a coworker of this individual, and they asked for a date. After the very first "no, please don't bring it up again" it becomes harassment.

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#8
post #6

The original story told about a couple of polite phonecalls where they have requested to talk with her. How does it get described as "harassment"? Of course, she also added a lot of paranoid speculation to her original blog post, but there's not a single confirmation of her fears so far, not even a hint.

>The original story told about a couple of polite phonecalls where they have requested to talk with her. How does it get described as "harassment"? As soon as they continued after the very first 'no' it becomes harassment. Imagine this was a work setting, the FBI was a coworker of this individual, and they asked for a date. After the very first "no, please don't bring it up again" it becomes harassment.

Only that this is not a sexual setting and the fact it is a "she" changes nothing in this context.

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#9
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>The original story told about a couple of polite phonecalls where they have requested to talk with her. How does it get described as "harassment"? As soon as they continued after the very first 'no' it becomes harassment. Imagine this was a work setting, the FBI was a coworker of this individual, and they asked for a date. After the very first "no, please don't bring it up again" it becomes harassment.

Only that this is not a sexual setting and the fact it is a "she" changes nothing in this context.

The point still stands. If a person tells you to stop an action they find uncomfortable for whatever reason in any way, no matter their gender, race, etc. It becomes harassment. The FBI is a government organization that you could argue has the job of doing this, however they fail to ever state why they require her assistance (and they seem kinda rude to me).

Re: FBI Harassing Core Tor Developer, Demand Meeting, but Refusing to Explain Why

#10
post #5

It sounds like her concern is that they might show her a magic piece of paper which, once you've seen it, requires you to do certain things and prohibits you from ever talking about it to anyone.[1] Magic pieces of paper like that really shouldn't be a part of our legal system. [1] https://epic.org/privacy/nsl/

They can email those to you.
Post reply on HN