Live data from Hacker News

Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

ideas.4brad.com

1–10 of 18 posts

Re: Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

#3
post #2

1) i thought this meant stock crash, but it refers to the bus / automated SUV crash from 2/29/2016 2) Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash, I'm curious if I have in my head the right idea about what actually happened

Not animated, but there's a diagram here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11197681

Re: Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

#6
post #2

1) i thought this meant stock crash, but it refers to the bus / automated SUV crash from 2/29/2016 2) Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash, I'm curious if I have in my head the right idea about what actually happened

> Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash

Was this a test-vehicle of Google? In that case, it probably had lots of cameras on board.

Re: Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

#7
post #2

1) i thought this meant stock crash, but it refers to the bus / automated SUV crash from 2/29/2016 2) Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash, I'm curious if I have in my head the right idea about what actually happened

Me too... I suggest to change the title, as it seems misleading.

Re: Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

#8
post #6
post #2

1) i thought this meant stock crash, but it refers to the bus / automated SUV crash from 2/29/2016 2) Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash, I'm curious if I have in my head the right idea about what actually happened

> Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash Was this a test-vehicle of Google? In that case, it probably had lots of cameras on board.

And Google is not going to release that footage, at least not anytime soon.

Re: Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

#9

I'm glad that nobody was hurt. It takes some of the emotion about getting to the fixes.

And it's still hard to argue with the fact that out of several million miles driven, this is the first serious accident that was caused by the autonomous car (and the failure scenario looks to have been appreciably complex). You won't find a human with that clean of a record.

Re: Google's self-driving car crash is a positive sign

#10
post #6
post #2

1) i thought this meant stock crash, but it refers to the bus / automated SUV crash from 2/29/2016 2) Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash, I'm curious if I have in my head the right idea about what actually happened

> Has anyone made an animated depiction of the crash Was this a test-vehicle of Google? In that case, it probably had lots of cameras on board.

Yes, it was an autonomous vehicle (with a "test driver" in the car)…there are more details on http://www.engadget.com/2016/02/29/google-self-driving-car-a...

What I find interesting is this comment: Our test driver, who had been watching the bus in the mirror, also expected the bus to slow or stop.

Post reply on HN