Check Your MX Records

#1

Post by mrideout » Sat, Oct 17, 2015, 11:07 PM UTC

Re: Check Your MX Records

#2

Post by Sephr » Sat, Oct 17, 2015, 11:43 PM UTC

This just looks like an ad for your service, Matt (which is usually okay and encouraged on HN, but this site requires signup to do anything). You should also use first person in your submission title as not to obscure your relation to the site.

Re: Check Your MX Records

#3

Post by mrideout » Sun, Oct 18, 2015, 12:19 PM UTC

Sephr wrote: post #2

This just looks like an ad for your service, Matt (which is usually okay and encouraged on HN, but this site requires signup to do anything). You should also use first person in your submission title as not to obscure your relation to the site.

Thanks for the feedback, Sephr. I'm new to posting on HN, and want to make sure I don't repeat any mistakes that were made when sharing this article.

I am the author of the article, and certainly don't want to obscure that. I'm gathering from your feedback that submitting this article to HN with a title of "How I Check My MX Records" would be more appropriate. Is that correct?

The article discusses MX record concepts, and potential problems, followed by three methods for checking MX records. Using the dig and nslookup commands are the first two methods, and the DNS Check service is the third. My intent is for the article to be be useful for someone using any of those options. Is sharing that type of article discouraged on HN?

I read through https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html before posting, and thought I was following those guidelines. Are there any additional guidelines that you recommend I review?