Live data from Hacker News

Will emoji become a new language?

bbc.com

1–10 of 35 posts

Re: Will emoji become a new language?

#3
A bit of click-baiting here, however it is quite interesting how long before :) or ;) etc. become widely accepted eg. in newspapers (assuming that newspapers don't go extinct first).

Re: Will emoji become a new language?

#4
The arguments the author makes around technological constraints precluding language development seem wrong in a few ways, but I'm not that familiar with the field, so the column may be short handing more sophisticated analysis. Specifically:

1. Most (all?) written languages are linear -- they are processed sequentially by the brain and then deeper meanings are extracted (particularly wrt metaphors and allegory, but also viz. complex sentence structure). Emoji are not unique on this count.

2. Paper and pen (the surfer example) also have technological constraints. It's a "2D" surface, width of line, etc.

3. The input difficulties of emoji today seems temporary. For example, a gesture interface to get you to the correct emoji.

4. What about non-alphabetic written languages?

These seem like obvious first-order responses to the article, so I suspect I'm missing something (besides my first cup of coffee).

Re: Will emoji become a new language?

#9
post #6

Why is this even a question asked? It's child-like gibberish!

I'm sure there are other forms of communication which seem child-like (and all foreign languages sound like gibberish to begin with)

Especially the forms of abbreviated communication that emoji tend to replace.
Post reply on HN