Live data from Hacker News

SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

news.ycombinator.com

91–100 of 347 posts

Re: SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

#91
post #59
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Addendum: well, crap. The future is still hard.

Your post was in my mind when I was watching the live stream. Your post was the first thing that I thought of when I realised what had happened.

Ditto, it made the situation so much sadder.

Re: SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

#92
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I heard this on the NASA stream... but don't quote me on this

You're quoting yourself here, what do you mean? If you're not supposed to say this then simply don't or do it with a throwaway.

"Don't quote me" means something like, I am not a reliable source and I could be wrong.

Re: SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

#95
Does anybody have a way to watch the video again? I'm curious to watch it again now that I know what happened. I haven't watched many launches before so I didn't know if what was happening was routine or not. Though, admittedly, it was weird that one second there was a rocket, then the next there was only debris...

edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZeiBFtkrZEw&t=23m38s Thanks xur17!

Re: SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

#98
post #63
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I saw two big puffs of smoke and initially thought it was the boosters releasing.

On the video it looked to me like a tank ruptured somewhere in the top half of the rocket, probably the second stage, and set free all the fuel. The rocket kept its course for some time until it suddenly disintegrated.

maybe the rupture was the initial bit of smoke (it looked the larger of the two from my view).

Re: SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

#99
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You're quoting yourself here, what do you mean? If you're not supposed to say this then simply don't or do it with a throwaway.

"Don't quote me" means something like, I am not a reliable source and I could be wrong.

Ah, I see. The English Language never ceases to surprise :)

Re: SpaceX – Launch Vehicle Failure

#100
post #58
post #50

As the ship exploded, the words on the screen were something to the tune of "At this point, the ship is under the highest aerodynamic pressure".

From the timeline, and from remembering past launches, I'm pretty sure it was well past Max-Q.

I think Max-Q occured about a minute before. You can review the stream, it passed supersonic way before (you see the shock cone on the two sides), then max-q, then a minute later the explosion
Post reply on HN