Live data from Hacker News

F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

bbc.co.uk

91–100 of 197 posts

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#91
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. The silly cost and stil 840 hp @ 1x,000 rpm is just a bunch of window dressing for the Lefties. The entire enterprise of F1 will never be "green", once you take into account the production of the cars, the crash repleacements, fuel used in training and lower Fxx series, and...the fact that these clowns fly all of this junk around the WORLD to drive. They are doing to f1 what they did to the America's cup. Ba…

Have you considered,that technologies developed for F1 by lets say....Mercedes, can later be used in their regular cars and therefore improve efficiency of not just a single F1 car,but millions of cars on the road? With the promotion of turbochargers in F1, a stupid amount of research is going to go into them - and they are used in pretty much every diesel car on the road now, so if the technology can be improved fur…

> With the promotion of turbochargers in F1

Then again, that follows their ban in 1989.

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#92
post #52

The interesting bit here is the development of the turbochargers. This is an area that has been slow to change over the years, due to the small amount of turbocharged vehicles available new[1]. Most turbos are used in heavy machinery (garbage trucks, big rigs, etc.), a slowly changing industry. They do not face the same regulations as regular autos. Seems they are doing away with the wastegate and replacing it with a…

[deleted]

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#93
post #4
post #2

But do they have to limit fuel. Does the advantage of the turbo outweigh more pitstops? I'm afraid races might get boring when drivers will have to conserve their fuel or just lose the race.

Cars going round in circles? I already find that fairly boring.

You should give the WRC series a good look. Here is Round 8 in Finland of the 2013 season. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82FgaYyXYwE

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not much. The top speed for controllable driving in a wheeled vehicle is in the 300mph range. The power and aerodynamics requirements to step up to 400mph are severe. Specifically, the wheel-driven land-speed record is a bit over 400mph (although just last year it climbed up to 440mph) and the vehicles capable of going that fast are nearly incapable of taking turns of any significance at those speeds. Jet powered veh…

Perhaps the turning could be improved if jets were used for steering as well? But by this point, you are effectively left with a rocket that just happens to have some circular things that touch the ground.

Just make the wheels optional and set a 1.5 meter flight ceiling.

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#95
post #52

The interesting bit here is the development of the turbochargers. This is an area that has been slow to change over the years, due to the small amount of turbocharged vehicles available new[1]. Most turbos are used in heavy machinery (garbage trucks, big rigs, etc.), a slowly changing industry. They do not face the same regulations as regular autos. Seems they are doing away with the wastegate and replacing it with a…

Most new vehicles today are turbocharged in Europe. Either turbo diesels or turbo charged petrol engines. Audi, VW, BMW, Mercedes actually have more turbo engines than normally aspirated in their lineup, much more in fact!

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#96
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree. The silly cost and stil 840 hp @ 1x,000 rpm is just a bunch of window dressing for the Lefties. The entire enterprise of F1 will never be "green", once you take into account the production of the cars, the crash repleacements, fuel used in training and lower Fxx series, and...the fact that these clowns fly all of this junk around the WORLD to drive. They are doing to f1 what they did to the America's cup. Ba…

Have you considered,that technologies developed for F1 by lets say....Mercedes, can later be used in their regular cars and therefore improve efficiency of not just a single F1 car,but millions of cars on the road? With the promotion of turbochargers in F1, a stupid amount of research is going to go into them - and they are used in pretty much every diesel car on the road now, so if the technology can be improved fur…

The £300 million that the f1 teams have wasted on these engines is a drop in the bucket compared to what all the manufacturers spend on their road cars. And none of the tech comes out of f1 , only in.

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#97
post #5

There are so many rules dictating the design of an F1 chassis/engine that I wonder how much faster a "anything goes" car would go.

Well, even Indy had to tone down the cars for places like Texas Motor Speedway because the drivers were passing out in the corners. Daytona and Talladega are run with restrictor plates in NASCAR for much the same reason.

The cars have been able to go faster than drivers can handle for a long time.

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#98
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> "I'd rather see wheel to wheel action than listen to the comments about how this guy in a second place will have to save his tires and give up positions to score a few points." The only reason he is in 2nd place is because he didn't save his tyres - and the reason he has to now lose places is because the guys behind did. In the end it usually works out the way it should be and we get some fighting on the last few…

Its a matter of taste I suppose. I did not enjoy this season. Maybe I'm too spoiled by MotoGP.

Well, what can I say, I agree, I think it's getting boring and too many artificial limitations.

But it's better than the Schumacher era, with absolutely no challenge to him.

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#99
post #65

I wrote firmware (~20kLocs) for a power (electrical) supply that's part of one such power train. This kind of development is very demanding, because you can't afford to leave any bugs in your program but at the same time you're always shipping late because of tight schedules and often blurry specifications. On top of that hardware and software development cycles are concurrent, so no target hardware available when yo…

as a huge F1 fan and software hacker id love to hear more, but i guess its all under NDA right ? :/

Re: F1 2014: All aboard the 'power train' - new rules explained

#100
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cars going round in circles? I already find that fairly boring.

That's NASCAR, not F1. In F1 you see real cars, doing real curves, not the thing NASCAR does like having a car that only could turn one way. In F1 you see cars going through the streets of Monaco or Valencia, or German circuits that you could race yourself with your own car. BTW I do it.

NASCAR has road tracks so stop the stupid and tell the truth.

I like NASCAR because F1 feels too teched up and NASCAR doesn't even give the driver a fuel gauge or speedometer. Plus all that weight and those small breaks. And just to stop another stereotype, I hate wrecks and cautions and I haven't met anyone who does.

NASCAR is also the most fan friendly sport with a huge amount of fan interaction with the drivers and cars. NASCAR fans can even go on the actual track in training vehicles.

Post reply on HN