Live data from Hacker News

Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

bbc.co.uk

91–98 of 98 posts

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#91

A "toxin" is something which is toxic to a system. But our knowledge of the brain is so primitive that we can't reasonably claim to know which chemicals are toxic at tiny, long-term dosage levels, unless it leads to death. There is no evidence that it's possible to die directly from sleep deprivation. Therefore this seems a dubious headline.

If you don't sleep for long enough (about 7 days), you'll start to have visual and auditory hallucinations and also delusional thinking. You'll also experience severely reduced effectiveness of just about every system in your body. You might not die if you don't sleep for a year (say), but you'll probably get permanent brain damage.

In clinical settings people experienced hallucinations with less than 48 hours of sleep deprivation.

http://www.amsciepub.com/doi/abs/10.2466/pms.1989.68.3.787?j...

I have no idea where you get 7 days from, I'm not sure its possible to stay awake for 7 days.

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm narcoleptic. Sleep paralysis happens pretty often to me and it still causes me distress almost every time until I "boot up" enough to realize what is going on. Hypnagogic hallucinations (at least that I remember) are quite a bit rarer and much more terrifying, since my brain pretty much dreams up the worst possible scenarios possible (burning building, demons, reapers, Sasquatch, being dead in a morgue drawer, an…

Don't forget the alien strobe lights. Sorry now you are gonna see that too. In all seriousness, wiggle your big toe. For some reason your fine motor controls are probably still online, and it will break you out of the hypnagogic state. Kill bill wasn't lying. But... if you wanna real trip, try to remain calm, still and breathe deeply through the hallucinations and keep in mind that nothing can hurt you (I like to rep…

For some odd reason, I don't really see flashing lights or anything extraterrestrial. I don't know why.

And wiggling my toes or fingers doesn't seem to ever work for me, but my phone buzzing or someone touching me breaks me out almost instantly.

As for the calm, "astral projecting" thing, I used to do some things like that and really enjoyed it, until I ended up "seeing" some jackal-headed monstrosity battling shadow people and something that looked like smoke with diamond shaped blazing yellow eyes.

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#93
post #79

This appears to have an interesting implication for FFI [1], a mysterious genetic disease that causes complete insomnia in adults and results in death. The final stage of FFI is dementia. It turns out that the β-amyloids that are cleared during sleep according to this paper, are associated with certain types of dementia in the general population [2]. It also turns out that certain sleep disorders are dementia predict…

Is it known if there are ways to support the cleanup process? I ask because due to allergies I have constant sinus congestions and as a result a very light sleep. On average I wake up (to the point where I'm consciously aware that I'm awake) 2 to 4 times per night, persumably due to lack of oxygen. I'm noticing memory issues; and while the process may not be reversable, I would like to halt it or at least slow it dow…

I have sleep apnea and use a CPAP machine nightly. My CPAP device comes with a humidifier chamber to keep the humidity of the air I breathe in high.

One of the side-effects of using a CPAP machine is that sinus congestion never bothers me as long as I have the device on. It provides enough pressure that my sinus are forced to remain open when turned.

So maybe look into using a CPAP machine to help you out.

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#94
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you don't sleep for long enough (about 7 days), you'll start to have visual and auditory hallucinations and also delusional thinking. You'll also experience severely reduced effectiveness of just about every system in your body. You might not die if you don't sleep for a year (say), but you'll probably get permanent brain damage.

In clinical settings people experienced hallucinations with less than 48 hours of sleep deprivation. http://www.amsciepub.com/doi/abs/10.2466/pms.1989.68.3.787?j... I have no idea where you get 7 days from, I'm not sure its possible to stay awake for 7 days.

On reflection, maybe I got confused with the number of days you can go without water (also 7, at least according to my memory). I stayed awake for 5 days once and there was only a bare minimum of hallucination at the end. I could have stayed awake longer, it wasn't really hard by that point. The people I've known who stayed up forever on crystal meth typically started hallucinating after a week. I'm surprised that the limit is so much shorter, but I'll believe it, thanks for the link.

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems unlikely. Essentially all animals with a brain sleep, even flies. You'd need to find a pill that could do something that not one animal was able to evolve to do over hundreds of millions of years. Something that was extremely calorie intensive is all I can imagine.

I appreciate your logic, but there is a wide variety of needed levels of sleep among different animals, and even among different individual humans which tells me that some are more efficient than others at sleeping (maybe clearing toxins?). As efficient as evolution is, the ability not to sleep as much may not be a huge determinant in reproduction. Just 100 years ago, people worked all day, then relaxed and slept. Th…

What is likely to be true is the pharmaceuticals will allow a conscious choice among a menu of tradeoffs, on a daily basis.

Such tradeoffs might be possible now, for those with sufficient discipline, but switching between very different ones is too hard.

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#96

Why does everyone in this thread want to get rid of sleep? I like sleeping, and dreaming. 24-7 consciousness in the name of increased productivity sounds like a nightmare, no pun intended.

How can you enjoy something you're not conscious of? What you likely enjoy is the 5-30 minutes as you're falling asleep, and the 5-60 minutes as you're waking up.

If we could get the actual sleeping time to 1 minute, but keep the rest the same, surely that would be strictly better in terms of human utility.

Re: Sleep Flushes Toxins from the Brain

#97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems unlikely. Essentially all animals with a brain sleep, even flies. You'd need to find a pill that could do something that not one animal was able to evolve to do over hundreds of millions of years. Something that was extremely calorie intensive is all I can imagine.

I appreciate your logic, but there is a wide variety of needed levels of sleep among different animals, and even among different individual humans which tells me that some are more efficient than others at sleeping (maybe clearing toxins?). As efficient as evolution is, the ability not to sleep as much may not be a huge determinant in reproduction. Just 100 years ago, people worked all day, then relaxed and slept. Th…

All animals are extremely vulnerable when they sleep. Yet they all do it.
Post reply on HN