Live data from Hacker News

The ﹤main﹥ element

html5doctor.com

91–93 of 93 posts

Re: The ﹤main﹥ element

#91
post #69

Question: is there any evidence that search engines actually use/respect semantic tags like , , , etc.? Or anyone here who knows firsthand from Google? Just because, if I were writing a search engine, I would already have a bunch of "AI"/heuristics logic to tease these things out, since most sites don't use semantic HTML5 -- and it would probably do a solid job, since it's easy to compare a bunch of pages from a sing…

From what I understand, the short answer is "No, they don't". The long answer is "They don't yet, but if we keep telling people they do and everyone starts using semantic HTML, they will".

> and everyone starts using semantic HTML, they will

Eh, I doubt it. The problem with the "semantic web" is that your semantics might not match my semantics. You might use only for the main content of an article-like page, whereas I might use it for each separate piece of text.

Re: The ﹤main﹥ element

#92
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Straightforward design meaning a never-ending single column of content? I would be shocked for such a page to require any creative usage of divs/spans whatsoever. Also, just curious, what's the point in having a footer that I can never properly see because new content is injected as I scroll down the page?

Re: footer – if you turn js off, it means that a 'more' link appears at the end of the page, leading you to older pages.

I would rather that the footer either be sticky or the injection of new content not happen. One shouldn't have to disable Javascript to see content, even if it is the footer.

Re: The ﹤main﹥ element

#93
post #84

The header goes inside of body now? If so then now header no longer means header. For that matter, main seems to be doing what body is supposed to do? Personally I think it should be: [...] [...] [...] Why change the expectations for where a header goes after around two decades?

Are you mistaking header and head?

Yes, you're right, I got them mixed up, thanks.
Post reply on HN