Live data from Hacker News

Bitcoin Tops $50USD on MtGox

mtgox.com

91–94 of 94 posts

Re: Bitcoin Tops $50USD on MtGox

#91
post #86
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

BTC may solve buyer-side fraud, but it creates a giant seller-side fraud problem.

I basically see advantages for the seller (lower fees, fraud protection), but none for the buyer (seller-side fraud potential, no cash-back). Therefore, why would I, a buyer use this vs a credit card?

Your thinking is too narrow. You are focused on the small subset of transactions where you use credit cards. Bitcoin is a solution to a much larger set of problems where credit cards do not work at all, or well enough.

Firstly, you just cannot use your credit card (or Paypal, or Western Union) to do certain transactions: sending any amount of money to a family member overseas (WU does not operate in many countries, and has limits), making a donation to an organization censored/oppressed by governments (PP blocks donations to Wikileaks), etc.

Secondly, even when you can use the traditional banking system, it is inconvenient: driving 30min to a WU office to receive money, waiting days for wire transfers to complete, etc.

Thirdly, your credit card is tied to an account that your government, bank, or a court can seize for whatever reason (your spouse making fraudulent claims during a divorce going badly, etc). Bitcoin protects you from that. With Bitcoin, you own a purchasing power that no one can regulate or block.

Fourthly, Bitcoin transactions fees are voluntary, hence very low: typically less than 0.01%. This benefits not only sellers, but also buyers. Credit card transactions cost 1-2% (even if you do not see them as a buyer, the seller increase its prices to cover them).

Fifthly, the USD in your account tied to a credit card depreciates over time, because the Federal Reserve prints money continuously (causing long-term inflation). Whereas with Bitcoin your purchasing power is preserved or increased over time, as the maximum number of Bitcoins is capped (causing long-term deflation). Therefore you do not have to resort to various more or less risky investment options to preserve your net worth over your lifetime.

Re: Bitcoin Tops $50USD on MtGox

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow, this is a fascinating list. So we know there are at least 25 bitcoin millionaires (bitcoin wallets with value > $1,000,000 USD).

For such large amounts, you can't simply calculate the number of bitcoins * price per bitcoin, since the act of selling such large amounts would itself affect the price.

Same applies to a lot of wealthy people in shares. If they sold all their shares, they'd make the share price plummet and they wouldn't get anywhere as much as you initially quoted.

As volume picks up (market depth has nearly tripled in 2 months) this is a lesser problem.

Re: Bitcoin Tops $50USD on MtGox

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Since transactions are irreversible, buyers need to fill less forms and have lower prices. Coindl.com sells you stuff with no registration/forms/emails - it shows a QR code and gives you a download button within two seconds after you sent a transaction. And buyer does not need to trust his CC details to new merchants. He only risks the amount to be paid, not the whole bank account.

But a compromised credit card doesn't mean you risk your whole bank account. First, at least in the US, there are limits to what you are liable if you are card is compromised -- report within 48 hours, the limit is $50, report within 60 days, the limit is $500. Second, credit cards have a credit limit -- so, worst case scenario, you'd be out to whatever your limit is (which is unlikely to happen as any weird use of y…

Compromised credit card adds significant hassle while Bitcoin transaction adds zero hassle. So CC is worse than Bitcoin for both parties: merchant can lose money and have to insure against it with paper work and higher prices, customer has to worry about reputation of a merchant and check his balance regularly, call the bank quickly etc.

Yes, if the merchant steals from the buyer, the raw BTC transaction is not reversible. But normally merchant has much more to lose than you if he is not nice (and merchants show their commitment by investing a lot in marketing and development) and in rare cases when you transact more money, you can use escrow and extra paperwork. But that's totally optional and is not needed when paying for a coffee, a book, or some inexpensive service.

Re: Bitcoin Tops $50USD on MtGox

#94
post #81
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just like alcohol use crashed with prohibition, or the drug market? Previous attempts to stop these have resulted in larger market shares of those willing to still do related business and almost always increases demand.

Illegality doesn't increase demand. It just means that the supply gets provided by shady criminals instead of legal business that follow the rules.

It increases the per-vendor demand as experienced by the vendors who stay in the market.
Post reply on HN