Live data from Hacker News

Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

swiftsilentdeadly.com

91–100 of 122 posts

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#91

I'm sure it exists, but we need this for movies. Of all the things I wish the movie industry would do, removing the sound of racking a slide or pulling back a hammer...on an automatic.. is top of my list of things that need to absolutely go.

This. Every movie shotgun uses the sound of a Remington 870 racking. Every camera uses the sound of a Nikon MD11/12 winding. I'm sure there are more.

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#92
post #75
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Possibly, but I can't imagine a writer taking that kind of chance at the height of the Cold War just for verisimilitude.

I mean, the way I imagine it is he chatted with one ore more guys and after a while he got bits here and there he was technically not supposed to have, not enough of its own, but with imagination enough to get the rough picture of how it worked and got very close. But I don't think conscious braking of classified information happened. More carelessness I guess.

That's what I've heard - intelligent research, combined with unclassified facts gleaned from conversations at coffeeshops and bars, led to a pretty accurate picture.

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#93
post #37

One thing I have noticed messed up in a lot of fiction (written/tv/movies/etc) is how loud guns actually are. Scenes of multiple people without any hearing protection emptying their guns that doesn't have any kind of supressors/silencer multiple times in a closed space (usually a single room) and then just casually chatting with each 5 seconds later. In general the sounds of guns are very bad in most movies/tv shows…

Michael Mann movies tend to get this right, Heat and collateral have really decent gun sounds. Turns out they are very loud.

Edit: just noticed you mentioned heat already, I need more coffee…

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#94

[flagged]

Dogs kill about 30-50 people in the U.S. every year. Intimate partner gun violence alone leads to about 700 women being killed every year. So by your logic, if you’re a woman and your partner has a gun, and is walking towards you and you can’t clearly tell that they don’t have a gun on them, “they just want to give you a kiss before leaving home” isn’t an argument. They’re vermin that can kill you and you’re absolute…

[flagged]

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#97

I'm sure it exists, but we need this for movies. Of all the things I wish the movie industry would do, removing the sound of racking a slide or pulling back a hammer...on an automatic.. is top of my list of things that need to absolutely go.

Please, these are more often than not just creative choices, sure they may be inaccurate but accuracy is seldom the point a director is trying to make when taking creative liberties like this.

If every movie was as close to reality as possible they wouldn’t be classified as entertainment.

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#98

[flagged]

Now this is certainly a take. A bad one, surely, but a take nonetheless.

Don’t pet strange dogs. Don’t let your children pet strange dogs. Don’t mess with animals you don’t know unless you’re willing to risk being bitten or worse. Simple as that.

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#99
post #84
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am a dog owner, and I agree that a loose and aggressive dog is a liability to humanity and you are making everyone a favor if you kill it even if you could have escaped (e.g. you manage to get into your car in time). If it was attacking you, it could be a child (or another dog, too) next time. I would say that even a loose, non aggressive dog of a breed that is very statistically likely to mangle people (e.g. Bully…

As a fellow dog owner I feel obligated to point out that not all barking is aggressive. People not used to dogs often seem to think it is, and I'd hate for people to start shooting dogs just because they bark. Dogs bark, it's what they do.

[flagged]

Re: Gun Mistakes in Fiction Writing: Handgun Edition

#100
post #37

One thing I have noticed messed up in a lot of fiction (written/tv/movies/etc) is how loud guns actually are. Scenes of multiple people without any hearing protection emptying their guns that doesn't have any kind of supressors/silencer multiple times in a closed space (usually a single room) and then just casually chatting with each 5 seconds later. In general the sounds of guns are very bad in most movies/tv shows…

Michael Mann movies tend to get this right, Heat and collateral have really decent gun sounds. Turns out they are very loud. Edit: just noticed you mentioned heat already, I need more coffee…

Just watch "that scene" from Heat again - it's like a double espresso.
Post reply on HN