Live data from Hacker News

If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

paulbuchheit.blogspot.com

91–100 of 117 posts

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#91
post #84
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Black... nail... polish... Solves every LED problem. Xerox, why did you think the power led on your multifunction should light up not only my home office, but the room next to it too?

Black electrical tape is even better. Because then it can be trivially peeled off later instead of requiring polish remover and a brush.

Yeah, but electrical tape looks like garbage. Trade off is aesthetics vs ability to remove easily.

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#92

Read something similar the other day about the original Walkman. The engineers wanted to add recording function, thinking it would help with sales and to only cost a negligible amount to add. Someone cleverer said no, because if you add that feature now people will be confused what it is for. If they don’t want to record audio, they’ll think the product isn’t for them.

Case in point: minidisc :) Recording was the killer feature for me. I recorded thousands of hours of band rehearsals with their stereo omni mics and the media quality.

Gotta love the LP4 mode. So much music on a single disk! Remember the cool rectangular batteries? Why aren't these gumstick batteries more used in modern devices!?

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#93
post #91
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Black electrical tape is even better. Because then it can be trivially peeled off later instead of requiring polish remover and a brush.

Yeah, but electrical tape looks like garbage. Trade off is aesthetics vs ability to remove easily.

There are various sizes/shapes of stickers intended to either dim or block led lights if aesthetics are important.

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#94
post #81
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More likely to go viral in that case, a headline saying "Walkmans sometimes record over your tapes!" When I was about 10, someone lent the school a tape of Holst's The Planets for a school play, one of the other students pressed the record button, and shortly thereafter the teacher played to the class a recording of me shouting "no stop" as I rushed for the stop button having seen what they'd done just a moment too l…

I thought that's what the little breakaway tabs on the bottom of the cassette are for Though I'll admit, when I used to use cassettes, I never write protected them

This story probably involves a cassette that someone copied at home and then didn’t break off that little tab.

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#96
post #66
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have been thinking deeply about this problem. I bought a great, silent fan from Rowenta, with beautiful housing and does what it says on the tin with no fancy accessories. 3 speed + 1 very silent mode for sleep. Hey, it’s a European product, not some Chinese knockoff. At some point during design, one person must have said “you know, why not add a brilliant white light that turns on in silent mode? Wouldn’t that be…

Black... nail... polish... Solves every LED problem. Xerox, why did you think the power led on your multifunction should light up not only my home office, but the room next to it too?

Thank you for this tip!

I have some Black 3.0 (blackest paint on earth) I'm gonna try this with!!!

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#97

In any case, the landing page needs to be perfect. Anything less and you have 0 chance. The most important innovation is in sales and marketing. If you don't have brand recognition, your landing page has to make up for that. Making up the difference seems to be getting more difficult with each passing year. People are extremely cautious and getting increasingly so. The average B2B user nowadays is literally triggered…

I've never been enticed by a landing page (yes, datapoint of one). It's either recommendation from source I trust (which has included reddit) and some demo/review available somewhere. Never the landing page as they usually took too much scrolling to get to the point.[0]. Better host a quick video demo/video add instead of drowning the user in copywriting. [0]: Compare https://nova.app/ and https://www.gnu.org/softwar…

The landing page is the worst place to get in touch with the reality of the product. Take a STEAM store page, it says nothing interesting about the game, doesn’t even has a gameplay video. Much better to just get to know the product with real people with real stories to tell, then the landing page is just the last place you go to acquire it. I never understood people who actually reads marketing copy and goes “hmm interesting”, it’s so vacuous and boring.

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#98
post #40

Read something similar the other day about the original Walkman. The engineers wanted to add recording function, thinking it would help with sales and to only cost a negligible amount to add. Someone cleverer said no, because if you add that feature now people will be confused what it is for. If they don’t want to record audio, they’ll think the product isn’t for them.

I have been thinking deeply about this problem. I bought a great, silent fan from Rowenta, with beautiful housing and does what it says on the tin with no fancy accessories. 3 speed + 1 very silent mode for sleep. Hey, it’s a European product, not some Chinese knockoff. At some point during design, one person must have said “you know, why not add a brilliant white light that turns on in silent mode? Wouldn’t that be…

Same problem with my electric toothbrush. And it’s super bright chafing light also FLASHES. Why? It must be a designer who hates everyone. It’s can’t be an accident.

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#99
post #94
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I thought that's what the little breakaway tabs on the bottom of the cassette are for Though I'll admit, when I used to use cassettes, I never write protected them

This story probably involves a cassette that someone copied at home and then didn’t break off that little tab.

I hope so, though my memory was it was in an official-looking cassette box.

Music back then wasn't cheap.

Re: If your product is Great, it doesn't need to be Good (2010)

#100
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I disagree here. That would be a marketing problem and I would have market it as for audio on the walk. With the focus on listening and the record option as a bonus.

Deciding on a product design that's easily marketable is also a marketing problem. You suggest adding it as a "bonus", but for whom? Recording what on the walk? How would you advertise that along the main feature people actually buy the thing for? If not, what purpose does it serve? It's a few cents, but that's still a few cents too much if that's not what you're convincing people to buy. Try to think of someone who…

This thread reminded me of Blaise Pascal's quip "I would have written a shorter letter, but did not have the time."

It's often easier to just throw in everything that's easy to do with little thought about cohesiveness or user experience. Leaving the record feature out of the walkman was likely a more difficult idea to push than including it and I think they were right.

Post reply on HN