Live data from Hacker News

A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

blog.lopp.net

91–100 of 248 posts

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#91
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I spend a lot of time filing requests to take down my home address. Most low-hanging fruit options have been scrubbed. I am hesitant to increase the count.

You mean the link between your name and home address? Impossible to scrub. If you're registered to vote, own a home, or many other things, that is legally a matter of public record.

Some people put their home in a trust to avoid this, and not everyone registers to vote.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#92
post #48
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

call your congress critter instead

what, they keep no records, or as lege branch they aren't foi-able so you won't ever know if they do or not?

They aren't publishing them on the web.

They probably do keep records, but something doesn't have to be perfect in order to be better.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#93

Any particular reason yall can't just argue in court that by creating opportunities for your PII to be stolen your governments (state or federal or both) are actively harming you economically? Sure, not much money to be had by fighting that fight but basically any PAC should have the means to do this and by claiming money is at stake and not people's actual safety you do have a better chance at this not being dismiss…

The government is allowed to create regulations that harm people economically. Not much money to be had by instantly losing that fight.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#94

"force phone providers to collect identity information from ordinary people before they can acquire or renew service with a phone carrier." don't see the harm in this? isn't this already the case for 99.9% of phoneline havers already?

Realistically, it is for 99.9% of people who have phones. The 0.1% have to go out of their way to buy, with cash or crypto, prepaid SIM top-ups on flip phones, and by doing so they stand out like a sore thumb. Back in the days of rotary phones, not only did the phone providers have your name, they even listed it, your home address, and your phone number in the white pages of the phone book, and everyone in town had a…

I grew up in the phone book age. We had one phone with a really long cable, but it wasn't long enough to take it with me everywhere I went. And, as you point out, nobody had robots to call it, either.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Counterpoint: for my part I would like it to be the case that any phone line that can dial or message my phone can be traced back to a known human being who can be held accountable for abuse of that phone line in terms of generating spam, abuse or harassment. Seems that we can’t both get what we want. A potential solution is that you get your anonymous phone line but my phone provider simply refuses to let you call m…

> Seems that we can’t both get what we want. Why can't you? They don't want to provide info for a credit check, you want human accountability. All that requires is for them to use a debit card for whatever service (prepaid or postpaid). Law enforcement can trace that if needed. No need for credit checks or really any other information directly in the hands of the telco.

Indeed. Given the KYC requirements for getting a credit card, it seems that paying with a credit card should confer traceability for LE.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#96
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I thought this was supposed to happen 5 years ago. Did they just chicken out on the prospect of actually shutting down telcos sending spam volume? It would certainly hurt a consumption-based economy, for starters.

Why would that hurt a consumption-based economy?

It's a vector for advertising.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#97
post #14

> Note: By checking this box, I acknowledge that I am filing a document into an official FCC proceeding. All information submitted, including names and addresses, will be publicly available via the web. Is there really not a way to submit an express FCC comment that avoids all my personal info being publicly published to the web? Yeesh.

Yes. You need to stand up as a citizen to have the impact (they cross check).

Publication is probably a bit much as a default and chills speech a bit, but it’s also important that the federal register can remain public with all public comment on the web. These are official comments on the record.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#98
"Call to Action" is a needlessly impotent threat. Like high school students walking out of their own lunch period to protest the loss of salisbury steak on the menu.

Most major telcos worldwide outside the US have strict KYC rules, this is not a battle you are going to win, because there are very few legitimate reasons in support.

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#99

Any particular reason yall can't just argue in court that by creating opportunities for your PII to be stolen your governments (state or federal or both) are actively harming you economically? Sure, not much money to be had by fighting that fight but basically any PAC should have the means to do this and by claiming money is at stake and not people's actual safety you do have a better chance at this not being dismiss…

The government is allowed to create regulations that harm people economically. Not much money to be had by instantly losing that fight.

Do those regulations often involve the creation and protection of the profit motive for foreign black markets?

Re: A Call to Action: Stop the FCC's KYC Regime

#100
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The crazy thing is that a simple 9-digit number (that you must give away for many things) can ruin your life if it gets public. The US seems so backwards at times.

at times? we can't even decide if women are allowed to control their own bodies. we're now open to states stopping people with dark skin from voting, and we have giant internment camps where we keep innocent men, women, children because they have a spanish accent. vaccines are apparently not a worldwide health miracle, education is overrated, we're bringing back jobs in coal and oil, and invading/destabilizing latin…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN