Live data from Hacker News

Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

nbcboston.com

91–100 of 105 posts

Re: Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Interesting this also happened in South Carolina and Ohio within the past few months. Not that interesting, apparently this scale of meteor happens on average multiple times a year, just not usually over such an urban area. The 2013 Chelyabinsk meteor (1) was larger and caused ground damage and injuries from e.g. flying glass from broken windows. > Sounds like the beginning of an alien invasion movie. Sleeper ships…

I think it's pretty interesting when something happens that rarely occurs in a populated area.

It's interesting in the personal sense that I have read multiple news articles about it, and checked to see if people heard it (they did).

It's not interesting in the scientific sense of being an outlier, unusual and noteworthy. It isn't, it's a common enough occurrence.

Re: Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

#95

The last I heard a meteor is a flash of light caused by a meteorite interacting with the atmosphere. Is this distinction, like 'lecturn', now dead?

My understanding of the terminology is that:

Meteor is a rock in space or in the atmosphere.

Meteorite is the rock after it touches the ground.

Falling/shooting star is the flash of light.

I have never heard of meteor being the flash of light.

Re: Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

#96
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The rest of the world, if they’re even mentioned in the plot, get one per country at most.

“France is the size of Ohio why would they send more ships to France than to Cleveland”

Really good wine and cheese?

Re: Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

#97
post #68
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Feels like a proper movie that political boundaries like state lines would be significant for all concerned. One meteor for Rhode Island, one for Texas... Any questions? (Asks the alien overlord of his minions in his crisp British accent)

The rest of the world, if they’re even mentioned in the plot, get one per country at most.

Europe gets one, under the eiffel tower.

Re: Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

#98
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you not consider Tunguska an explosion? It’s always described as such. IIRC, it never even hit the ground. Sure, a lot of the damage was caused by the air being compressed from above, but it created an air burst, which would have released a lot of energy in every direction.

No, it's a misnomer as with any other meteor. If you were to witness the breakup from the bolide's reference frame and without all the rushing air you'd never call it an explosion.

> and without all the rushing air

That's the exploding bit though. You don't need containment, you just need the the airburst. A hyper-heated pocket of air that then expands rapidly is itself an explosion.

Re: Meteor Explodes over Massachusetts

#100
post #35

"230 tons of TNT" I hate units of TNT. Ill do psi. Love the foot. The calorie is metric! But what on planet earth is "ton of TNT"? The energy that was dissipated (using 0.5 mv^2) was 1TJ, or the 280 000 kWh.

It's the most common unit for describing the explosive yield of a nuclear weapon. So, it's a lot smaller than the bombs dropped on Japan in WWII, but a lot bigger than a Davy Crockett. That's a sort-of-useful frame of reference. The only other things I can think of that would create a similar kind of blast are a volcanic eruption or something like that fertilizer explosion in Beirut in 2020 (~1100 tons TNT equivalent…

To be clear, I know what it is. In fact, I'm probably one of the few in the site who could guesstimate how much energy it is without looking it up (covalent reactions, per mole are equally energetic to within a fairly narrow margin; thats why, hydrocarbons are more less equally energetic)

But it's meaningless, unless you're a demolitions engineer. What's the volume of a ton of TNT? I guess - within a factor of two - about the same as a ton of water? So a cubic meter? Who knows?

Post reply on HN