Live data from Hacker News

California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

kcra.com

91–100 of 118 posts

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#91
post #6

Given that school budgets are absolutely gutted with mass layoffs this year and next, and the miscalculation looks like 2/3 of the budget shortfall, hiding such a basic and impactful error requires a much better explanation than I see in that article. It looks like it was done to stifle debate about budget allocations, which would be necessary in the circumstances.

The education system seems one of the only places where vastly improving technology over the past 30 years has not translated to cost savings or improved outcomes.

It shouldn't be surprising when you see what the educational technology money is actually spent on. Ive seen like a dozen "smart boards" purchased by my schools from the 00's and never once seen one used. Or how about the completely dog shit computer testing software that fails one-two word answers based on random capitalization or punctuation with no indication on what they expect. Each thing sold as the solution to all the past problems, but introducing more problems itself without actually solving any old ones.

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#92
post #80
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Someone still has to coordinate with Aramark. Data-processing specialist and print-center technician both sound like fancy names for secretarial roles. You're honestly saying schools need fewer counselors in what has been generally regarded as the worst generation for child mental health in years?

Bring food same time everyday? Here's a weekly food menu, repeat weekly? Whew, that's a lot of work. Email me if you need me. I'll be in Hawaii. Counselors aren't qualified to deal with mental illness.

you can tell this is someone who hasn't been in an operations role^

and sure, counselors aren't qualified to deal with mental illness

but what exactly do you believe is a child's path to qualified help if their parents are unengaged or the source of the problems?

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#93
post #6

Given that school budgets are absolutely gutted with mass layoffs this year and next, and the miscalculation looks like 2/3 of the budget shortfall, hiding such a basic and impactful error requires a much better explanation than I see in that article. It looks like it was done to stifle debate about budget allocations, which would be necessary in the circumstances.

The education system seems one of the only places where vastly improving technology over the past 30 years has not translated to cost savings or improved outcomes.

in this thread: people discover Baumol's cost disease

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#94

"Gov. Newsom in January projected the state would have to grapple with a $2.9 billion shortfall. The confirmed miscalculation means that shortfall could be much smaller." So, the title is just plain misleading. California is less in deficit than they earlier calculated.

[deleted]

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oregon's kicker law is a textbook example of bad economic policy, sadly. It essentially means that in boom years the state can't accumulate any general funds for recessions, which is half of the point of a state-level political entity in the first place. Balanced budgets and pay as you go are fabulous over the medium term, but over the short term of a year or two during a disaster or recession, governmental spending…

> in boom years the state can't accumulate any general funds for recessions Genuine question: have states had the discipline not to raid these coffers in the boom years? The alternative is borrowing in downturns. That works because during recessions interest rates are low. The opposite problem then manifests, however, which is the state continuing to borrow through the recovery. Maybe instead of citing shortfalls and…

> have states had the discipline not to raid these coffers in the boom years?

"Let's give the money back to voters because they will like that and we'll figure out something else in tough years" is, like, the quintessential example of "raiding these coffers."

It's basically like big tech companies turning profit into stock dividends because investors love it and the CEO will be handsomely rewarded, and who cares about long-term R&D. When big companies do that we blame MBAs and capitalism.

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#96
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is that related? That's a long term calculation error vs short term forecasting error.

From my point of view, the Jedi are a state-funded militia coded as a tax exempt non profit!

Why does tax exemption matter if they are state-funded?

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The education system seems one of the only places where vastly improving technology over the past 30 years has not translated to cost savings or improved outcomes.

It turns out that our kids learn better from humans than machines. Ever dealt with a kid who has had too much screen time? It’s fucking awful.

[deleted]

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#98
post #6

Given that school budgets are absolutely gutted with mass layoffs this year and next, and the miscalculation looks like 2/3 of the budget shortfall, hiding such a basic and impactful error requires a much better explanation than I see in that article. It looks like it was done to stifle debate about budget allocations, which would be necessary in the circumstances.

The education system seems one of the only places where vastly improving technology over the past 30 years has not translated to cost savings or improved outcomes.

Technology needs to form a union if it wants to fight existing union structures.

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#99
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Which of those roles specifically would you say are fluff? Food-services manager (it's all oursourced to Aramark), data-processing specialist, print-center technician, senior clerical assistant, one of registrar or attendance, two of site maintenance, one of the network specialists (probably both–one across the district is plenty), and probably at least one of the counselors and the separate social science & athlet…

Someone still has to coordinate with Aramark. Data-processing specialist and print-center technician both sound like fancy names for secretarial roles. You're honestly saying schools need fewer counselors in what has been generally regarded as the worst generation for child mental health in years?

>Someone still has to coordinate with Aramark

Like an AI? Get ready because the world that is coming is going to eat back at Chronus' puerile preferences.

Re: California has more money than projected after admin miscalculated state budget

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Someone still has to coordinate with Aramark As a full-time position? Aramark literally ran the lunch counters. I could see it being a district-level position, though it would be better positioned as a general procurement role. > Data-processing specialist and print-center technician both sound like fancy names for secretarial roles I agree. I was suspicious when I didn't see a secretary for each of the assistant p…

> One of the counselors didn't deign to meet with students. Why would she? That'd distract her from the actually important work of fabricating the reports that make her looking amazingly competent. My mom is a retired teacher and her main complaint during the last 10-15 years of work was that with all the bullshit paperwork they're required to fill, the teachers literally don't have the time to just plain interact wi…

An institution of education is a weapon against a society from actually existing. Technology has eaten our world and is shitting us out in real time.
Post reply on HN