Live data from Hacker News

South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

theregister.com

91–100 of 142 posts

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#91
post #90
post #67

To quote something from a favorite fiction-series, where someone is visiting a relatively backwards planet: > "Poor?" said Cordelia, bewildered. "No electricity? How can it be on the comm network?" > "It's not, of course," answered Vorkosigan. > "Then how can anybody get their schooling?" > "They don't." > Cordelia stared. "I don't understand. How do they get their jobs?" > "A few escape to the Service. The rest prey…

To turn to other, much older publications... The US Constitution was written ~230 year ago, when the state of the art was carrying letters by horse, and it explicitly authorized making a public service to provide it scale, which became the US Postal Service. If the same ideals and priorities had been applied against today's technology, we'd have the US Networking Service. Certainly not a deluxe ISP (even today USPS e…

I completely agree with this sentiment. Good luck getting anything like that locked, sadly.

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#92
post #67

To quote something from a favorite fiction-series, where someone is visiting a relatively backwards planet: > "Poor?" said Cordelia, bewildered. "No electricity? How can it be on the comm network?" > "It's not, of course," answered Vorkosigan. > "Then how can anybody get their schooling?" > "They don't." > Cordelia stared. "I don't understand. How do they get their jobs?" > "A few escape to the Service. The rest prey…

malka older's "infomocracy" is another interesting science fiction look at universal access to information

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's like saying that using tax dollars to pay for roads assumes that everyone has a car. MOST people do use things like government/taxpayer funded roads, public transportation, water, healthcare, etc that are considered as basic necessities. As far as everyone needing a smartphone, or e-mail address, that ship has already sailed. Here in the US, try using "Parkmobile" without a mobile phone.

> that ship has already sailed "Tell me what you eat and I'll tell you what you are." Anyways, if you actually just say, "I don't have a smartphone" you'll be surprised at how accommodating the world remains. > try using "Parkmobile" without a mobile phone Okay: https://support.parkmobile.io/hc/en-us/articles/368547636077... Was that supposed to be impossible?

Where in that link are instructions provided for someone to use it without a mobile phone? I see instructions for calling, but that still requires a mobile phone (or if we're being generous, a street with a payphone nearby).

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#94
post #90
post #67

To quote something from a favorite fiction-series, where someone is visiting a relatively backwards planet: > "Poor?" said Cordelia, bewildered. "No electricity? How can it be on the comm network?" > "It's not, of course," answered Vorkosigan. > "Then how can anybody get their schooling?" > "They don't." > Cordelia stared. "I don't understand. How do they get their jobs?" > "A few escape to the Service. The rest prey…

To turn to other, much older publications... The US Constitution was written ~230 year ago, when the state of the art was carrying letters by horse, and it explicitly authorized making a public service to provide it scale, which became the US Postal Service. If the same ideals and priorities had been applied against today's technology, we'd have the US Networking Service. Certainly not a deluxe ISP (even today USPS e…

I’ve always thought it a travesty that USPS doesn’t provide a public email service

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#96
post #66
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In SF, I commonly see homeless people with cell phones

That may say more about needs than affordability.

It's clearly affordable if it can be afforded. Otherwise nothing is affordable.

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#97

Seems nice but is actually a terrible move. It's another step towards the presumption that everyone should have a smartphone.

That's like saying that using tax dollars to pay for roads assumes that everyone has a car. MOST people do use things like government/taxpayer funded roads, public transportation, water, healthcare, etc that are considered as basic necessities. As far as everyone needing a smartphone, or e-mail address, that ship has already sailed. Here in the US, try using "Parkmobile" without a mobile phone.

> That's like saying that using tax dollars to pay for roads assumes that everyone has a car.

Not really. Roads carry goods, and they carry emergency vehicles. Pretty universal.

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#98
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To turn to other, much older publications... The US Constitution was written ~230 year ago, when the state of the art was carrying letters by horse, and it explicitly authorized making a public service to provide it scale, which became the US Postal Service. If the same ideals and priorities had been applied against today's technology, we'd have the US Networking Service. Certainly not a deluxe ISP (even today USPS e…

I completely agree with this sentiment. Good luck getting anything like that locked, sadly.

[flagged]

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But given how essential the internet is to everything we do on a daily basis, that makes a lot of sense. Well, water is certainly more essential, yet it isn't free. Food isn't free. Shelter isn't free. Besides, the services you'd use over this free connection aren't (necessarily) free. Its not unreasonable to suspect some other agenda, like easier propaganda, subsidising of social media, ...

Maybe the reduction in gov paper forms printing and processing, offset the mobile costs.

I often hear the argument of savings in printing and postage.

Having seen all the over budget, years delayed or completely failed IT projects in the public sector, I wonder whether there are any savings at all in the end.

(Perspective from a couple of EU countries at different degrees of digitalization)

Re: South Korea introduces universal basic mobile data access

#100
post #94
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To turn to other, much older publications... The US Constitution was written ~230 year ago, when the state of the art was carrying letters by horse, and it explicitly authorized making a public service to provide it scale, which became the US Postal Service. If the same ideals and priorities had been applied against today's technology, we'd have the US Networking Service. Certainly not a deluxe ISP (even today USPS e…

I’ve always thought it a travesty that USPS doesn’t provide a public email service

And pgp certificate signing
Post reply on HN