Live data from Hacker News

Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

news.ycombinator.com

91–100 of 232 posts

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#91
post #5

LOL "The entity is named “Beignet,” presumably because “Off-Balance-Sheet Leverage Vehicle No. 5” tested poorly with focus groups."

It’s a fitting name for Louisiana at least. But this place is next Monroe which is…nowhere near New Orleans.

We get it you want it to be named Boudin

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#92
post #31
post #8

[flagged]

Is Meta actually obligated to repay the loans or not? That’s how you can decide if this is disingenuous or not. If Meta is obligated to repay the loan and used to synthetic means to get it off the balance sheet that’s a problem. If they have in fact successfully transferred risk to other parties then that’s what deals like this are for. It’s the whole reason the concept of limited liability exists. I am fully willing…

>Is Meta actually obligated to repay the loans or not?

They aren't, but they're obligated to pay leases for it (they can't just build the datacenter and then walk away), which is kind of like having to repay the "loans".

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#93
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No one is lying or deceived here.

It’s not necessarily lying, but it’s certainly deceptive.

Not even deceptive. This is relatively normal business practice.

It’s easier to think of this as “project risk” as opposed to corporate risk overall.

This isn’t different than creating a subsidiary to embark on a new program, with its own debts and assets, collateralized by a parent company.

It’s effectively the same as what happens every time a major movie studio starts a new film project.

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#94

Folks in the comments here begging ChatGPT to teach them how to read

This article is poorly written. It’s so desperate to be clever and edgy that it’s hard to get the facts out of it. ChatGPT isn’t really a solution because the source is both low quality and has questionable motives. Going to any of the other good articles on the subject that have been linked in this comment section is much better.

It's actually written quite well, you just have to understand the underlying financial documents and methodology.

Things that are hard to read because you lack context is not the same as poor writing.

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#96
post #58
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If the llc declares bankruptcy does meta have to pay the bank for it - or can they buy the assets at fire sale prices?

Mechanistically, how would the LLC achieve bankruptcy?

Meta would have to not renew the lease and somehow nullify the residual value guarantee. This would leave the LLC with no revenue at all. If the RVG works there should be no chance of bankruptcy.

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#97
post #64

> This treatment is considered acceptable because the people who decide what is acceptable have accepted it. Wasn't that the root of the 2008 crash? The debt spiral was acceptable because people were making enough money in the present that regulators were powerless to advise against it. In a sane world people often go to jail for decades when doing this at pennies on the dollar.

The 2008 crash was in part caused by inaccurately rating synthetic bundles of subprime mortgage debt as extremely low risk (e.g. AAA). Subprime borrowers had a much higher risk of defaulting than a AAA rating implied. On the other hand, Meta has great creditworthiness. And guarantees this vehicle. So... it's not the same.

Until they don't. Lest we forget that Facebook's new handle was borne out of a pivot that's sunk almost a hundred billion dollars while being having been largely sidelined/abandoned. (I know that they're still doing a good deal of R&D, which is good, and a worthy investment, but 1) Carmack left, and 2) We apparently don't judge corporations on whether or not they're contributing to society, but only on whether they're in the red or black.)

Re: Credit report shows Meta keeping $27B off its books through advanced geometry

#100
post #8

[flagged]

This might be the first time an explicit ChatGPT response survived being the top comment I personally think it’s a great response and makes it clearer what’s happening Times are changing quickly!

Seriously. I thought about doing the same because I couldn't make heads or tails of the article, and then assumed it would just all be downvotes... glad to see it wasn't.
Post reply on HN