Live data from Hacker News

I don't like curved displays

blog.danielh.cc

91–100 of 137 posts

Re: I don't like curved displays

#91
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a cost thing, ultrawide has always been expensive relative to how much extra area you get, and pushing the resolution up compounds that. 5120x2160 (extended 4K) panels do exist but they cost a fortune.

And not in OLED, only in VA panels, unfortunately. I can't justify going high end on a monitor without it being OLED.

IPS ultrawides also exist, the U4025QW I have is one.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#92

I like my curved ultra-wide. I didn't at first, but my brain has very noticeably adapted to where curved things on it appear straight just fine. I noticed this when I went back to the office after a few weeks absence, where I have a regular flat pancake screen in 16:9, and straight text looked CURVED in the opposite direction! Brains are weird.

I've noticed the same when I tried to replace my ultrawide 34" with a Dell U3225QE for my home office the other day. I really wanted to like the Dell since I love the specs, but my head would hurt from the perceived bulge in the middle of the screen, where the curve used to sit farthest before. Stupid brains, really.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#93
post #22

As someone who wears corrective lenses for astigmatism, I can guarantee that what you perceive as a straight line, assuming you are human, is not, until your brain corrects it and signals 'straight line' to you. It takes a day or so for your brain to get used to any consistent distortion and totally disregard it. This is just pointless complaining... A bigger complaint with curved screens is: crazy reflections.

As someone who wears corrective lenses for astigmatism, I can guarantee that what you perceive as a straight line, assuming you are human, is not, until your brain corrects it and signals 'straight line' to you. That is unrelated to astigmatism. In Art 101 class in college we explored this phenomenon. It's caused by the spherical nature of the human eyeball. The exercise was to sit on the floor in the corner of a par…

Yeah. If you try hard enough, you can slightly break the correction and directly notice the curvature of the straight lines, especially long ones moving towards you, on the border of your visual field. The eye physically produces a heavily distorted picture, but it's at least partially rectified and the brain does a sort of continuous neural SLAM, what you perceive is the result of it.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#94
post #78
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I got a curved 5k2k lg display for games, and every time I switch to work monitor (5k regular flat lg), it feels like I'm looking at an old CRT that's bulging out at me. Such a strange sensation. I do like the curved display a lot however.

Wow, that's a great insight and honestly a great point for not having one. At least till they get more popular.

To be fair, this is a short lived effect immediately after transition. Goes away in 2 minutes.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#95
post #81
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm fairly certain such regulations don't exist anywhere. They would be far too easy to exploit, raising the cost of doing business and exposing them to outright fraud. Regulations meant to protect consumers usually protect them from dishonst business practices. The type of return you're talking about is usually intended to encourage people to make a purchase and to protect the reputation of a business. Yet the momen…

This is 100% a European law that exists. You are entitled returns within 14 days of purchase for most goods. No reason need be provided.

Huh, TIL.

This is something I always wanted here in Australia; hopefully we get enough push for it one day given our otherwise good consumer protection laws.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#96
Curved for games makes a lot of sense because it can emulate the 3D camera's Field of View making it more naturally display a wrap around world.

I also do a lot of VR stuff and those lenses are a whole different kind distortion. You get used to it super fast. You can really mess with the perception of visual reality in VR, and the brain is very good at just accepting the new reality and adjusting.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#97
This is so true. Glad someone posted about it. But ofcourse, the buyers won't care. They are easily sold with the idea that the far edges of the screen have low angle of view if the screen isn't curved. When people believe myths, sell them myths. When they believe the purpose of computers and phone is to share photos and videos, sell them fb and ig.

Also, for companies buying the curved monitors, the looks of the monitors across the workplace fit nicely into their "modernization" targets. No physics needed.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#98
post #97

This is so true. Glad someone posted about it. But ofcourse, the buyers won't care. They are easily sold with the idea that the far edges of the screen have low angle of view if the screen isn't curved. When people believe myths, sell them myths. When they believe the purpose of computers and phone is to share photos and videos, sell them fb and ig. Also, for companies buying the curved monitors, the looks of the mon…

I’ve recently been using (in different locations) a flat 27” 4K, a flat 32” 4K, and an old (2018) 34” curved 3440x1440.

I find the flat 32” too large to use at normal desktop distances, because the corners are in a bad position/distance/angle to actually read easily. This isn’t a “myth”, it’s what I experience.

For me, the curved 34” doesn’t have this problem. The only problem I find with it is its resolution is too low for its size (i.e. low DPI).

As a result I actually like the flat 27” best, but I suspect a larger curved monitor with higher DPI would be nice.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#99

I don't mind curved screens, but what I do mind is that so many wide / curved screens have such low vertical resolution. 1440px is just so little space.

For a 34 incher, 1440px is perfect, and so is a 34 incher. A higher resolution renders text too small to read, and a larger monitor has one moving their head around instead of just their eyes. Of course, they are not ideal for the graphical work that the author implies, but they can't be beat for productivity work imho.

> A higher resolution renders text too small to read

This is a misunderstanding of what higher resolution is for. Higher resolution allows text at exactly the same size to be much sharper and crisper. I have a 34” curved 1440p, and it’s like using a monitor from the pre-HD era in terms of sharpness. Other people in this thread have observed the same thing. The idea that it’s “perfect” is unfathomable to me.

Re: I don't like curved displays

#100

I don't mind curved screens, but what I do mind is that so many wide / curved screens have such low vertical resolution. 1440px is just so little space.

> 1440px is just so little space. 1440px tall on a common 13 tall ultrawide is 107 PPI. In my mind > 100 PPI is pretty much perfect for most tasks. Or are you talking about physical size?

Try using a 27” 4K monitor, which has a PPI of around 163. It’s difficult to go back to considering 100 PPI “perfect”.
Post reply on HN