Live data from Hacker News

The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

calvin.sh

91–100 of 578 posts

Re: The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

#91
> For all we know, the middle is just air and crumpled-up old newspaper.

I think this is the answer. I suspect the exhibit designers had a cool idea for a display, did a rough estimate of the area needed and then commissioned the exhibit builders to make the big metal-framed cube. Either they made an error in their calculation or the innate variability in the size of stacks of used bills threw it off. It's also possible the exhibit designer simply decided a bigger cube which filled the floor to ceiling space would be a better visual. Which would be unfortunate because, personally, the exhibit concept I'm more interested in is "$1M dollars in $100 bills fits in this area" not "Here's $1M in bills." The first concept is mildly interesting while the second is just a stunt.

Regardless of the reason it's off, I think it's most likely there's only $1M of bills in the cube. The folks responsible for collecting and destroying used bills tend to be exacting in their auditing for obvious reasons. So when the exhibit designers got $1M in used bills approved and released, that's exactly how much they got. It also stands to reason that they'd design the cube a little bigger than their calculated area requirement to ensure at least $1M would fit (along with some method of padding the interior) - although >50% seems excessive for a variability margin, so I still think it was an aesthetic choice or calculation error. Of course, one could do a practical replication to verify the area required with $10,000 in $1 bills.

Regardless, it's an interesting observation and a cool counting program to help verify.

Re: The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

#96
post #27

counting things are a huge intellectual blind spot. For some reason, when people hear a figure, they accept it as gospel. sums, averages, population, budgets, spending, rates. Counting things is time consuming and error prone. Ask a casino. You can have 3 people count something and come to a different figure off by a few percent. Seriously if someone says there's $1m in there, who is going to second guess? Thankfully…

Makes you wonder if all those pallets of cash we sent Iran really contained all the money we said it did. Also makes me wonder how you count money that arrives on pallets like that? Do you set up a warehouse full of money counters?

My wife works at a legit, long-established, high volume retail store. Some of the time she keeps books there. They just weigh money, it’s accurate enough for them.

Re: The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

#97
post #90

Did they ever consider there could be a hollow core, or filler to account for the discrepancy?

Yes, I used my eyes to read the article and I can confirm that they did consider it, because they wrote it down in the article we are discussing.

Re: The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

#98

I wouldn't be surprised if the bills themselves are marked with specimen or something on the non-visible side. Maybe they're also artificially worn bills produced during bringup or testing.

I agree. The "money" probably has the shape and appearance of money, but isn't legal tender out of concern risk management and theft.

The cube is almost certainly hollow, to cut weight and cost.

It's the idea of what a cube of $1m would look like. It should at least fulfill that requirement faithfully.

Re: The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

#99
post #83

Why in the world would you use KaTeX to write a number that is just being used as a number, not part of a mathematical formula? But, if you must, at least use some tricks to make the spacing work correctly: since TeX treats `,` as `mathpunct`, you need to use something like `\$1{,}000{,}000` (or change its catcode) to get something that renders as a plain old non-KaTeXed "$1,000,000" would.

thanks for the tip! I just wanted all the numbers to look the same

Re: The Fed says this is a cube of $1M. They're off by half a million

#100
post #90

Did they ever consider there could be a hollow core, or filler to account for the discrepancy?

The exhibit rotates. It will have the same kind of structure shown at the bottom through the middle of it at the very least, and probably a sort of skeleton for stability.
Post reply on HN