Live data from Hacker News

Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

annehelen.substack.com

91–100 of 318 posts

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#91

The gig economy is way worse than the author describes. Gig workers can't advance with the companies they work for. Gig workers can't build a network with their coworkers because they don't have coworkers...and there's a good chance that they are competing for work with other people working for the same company. There are dead end day jobs, and then there is gig work.

Gig workers are casual labor. Like Dickens with less coal dust.

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#92
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also this push to measure everything means that anything that can’t be measured isn’t valued. One of your teammates consistently helps unblock everyone on the team when they get stuck? They aren’t closing as many tickets as others so they get overlooked on promotions or canned. One of your teammates takes a bit longer to complete work, but it’s always rock solid and produces fewer outages? Totally invisible. Plus the…

It's even got a name: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McNamara_fallacy

It's got a name and we know that it's happening yet the overpaid overeducated c-suite demands it? What gives?

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#93
post #12

> At Fred Meyer, our local Kroger-owned grocery store, a bagger in his 70s put all my frozen items in a normal bag, and my chips in the cold storage bag I’d brought from home. A) Having to work a job (obviously not done out of passion) 70+ is really disheartening B) I don´t understand why this even is something that has to be done by a worker. I bought the groceries. I know where I want my stuff in my bags. Or I just…

> I don´t understand why this even is something that has to be done by a worker. I bought the groceries. I know where I want my stuff in my bags.

... You are literally describing self checkout which is very popular in grocery chains like Kroger and Publix. (In the U.S.).

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's even got a name: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McNamara_fallacy

It's got a name and we know that it's happening yet the overpaid overeducated c-suite demands it? What gives?

There's chance that maybe there exists a revenue stream that increases by further applying that policy across a system that you don't have access to?

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#95
post #89
post #12

> At Fred Meyer, our local Kroger-owned grocery store, a bagger in his 70s put all my frozen items in a normal bag, and my chips in the cold storage bag I’d brought from home. A) Having to work a job (obviously not done out of passion) 70+ is really disheartening B) I don´t understand why this even is something that has to be done by a worker. I bought the groceries. I know where I want my stuff in my bags. Or I just…

A low stress, easy job like that could totally be done out of choice. A big concern of seniors in my life is fearing cognitive atrophy from lack of social connections.

Retail is not "low stress". I guarantee you that senior bagger is getting chewed out every single day both by his customers and his management for being too slow hurry up already, packing the eggs at the bottom of the bag omg what are you doing you fucking idiot, etc.

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#96
post #29

In Germany you have quite high minimum wages. Unions and works committees are quite common. Labor protected laws are quite strict. Sure, not every job is fun, but living with low income is not as bad as in the US. So, are people better at their jobs? Nope. Do people work better just because you pay them better? Nope. Should people get paid better, especially those with shirty jobs? Yes - of course. But there’s no rea…

Germany in my experience is a country of too many scammers. Right from the taxi driver to the entrepreneurs, it is about cheating the customer. The funny thing is that it is native Germans who do it. Of course not everyone is like it, and there are plenty of top-notch open source developers that call Germany home.

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#97
post #74

The solution is simple; quit jobs, assemble our own shit. In the US, lean in to the 2A and tell the We peacefully assemble around jobs . Just peacefully assemble around a new meme of telling the walking dead to pound sand. Education worked to an extent; most will not devolve into dumb fucks. Pretty pathetic seeing the adults kowtowed by the ossified establishment.

Did you read the part where the OP was unable to assemble her own shit, and thus had to get help?

It was the OP's choice and mistake to buy a complex design that was difficult to self-assemble. Any number of simple metal bed frames bought online can trivially be assembled by a single person. Never give up your power unnecessarily.

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#98
post #3

I have been in the workforce for almost 30 years now and I believe that everybody is getting more squeezed so they don’t have the time or energy to do a proper job. The expectation is to get it done as quickly as possible and not do more unless told so. In SW development in the 90s I had much more time for experimentation to figure things out. In the last years you often have some manager where you basically have to…

How much more expensive is your time for the company now vs the 90s?

counting in cost of living increases? Probably about the same.

Re: Are people bad at their jobs or are the jobs just bad?

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In the last years you often have some manager where you basically have to justify every thing you do and always a huge pile of work that never gets smaller. So you just hurry through your tasks. This has been my exact experience. Absolutely everything is tracked as a work item with estimates. Anything you think should be done needs to be justified and tracked the same way. If anything ever takes longer than the est…

It's fascinating that you end up sort of doing the work twice, you build an excel (or jira) model of the work work along with the actual work to be done. Often this extends to the entire organization, where you have like this parallel dimension of spreadsheets and planning existing on top of everything. Eats resources like crazy to uphold.

Jira is already almost like "productivity theater" where engineers chart the work for the benefit of managers, and managers of managers only. Many programmers already really resent having to deal with it. Soon it will be a total farce, as engineers using MCP Jira servers have LLMs chart the "work" and manage the tickets for them, as managers do the same in reverse, instructing LLMs to summarize the work being done in Jira.

It'll be nothing but LLMs talking to other LLMs under the guise of organizational productivity in which the only one deriving any value from this effort is the companies charging for the input and output tokens. Except, they are likely operating at a loss...

Post reply on HN