Live data from Hacker News

Being Raised by the Internet

jimmyhmiller.github.io

91–100 of 331 posts

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#91
post #17

It's fascinating how someone can feel like they've been "raised by the internet," almost as if it’s a parent in this digital age. I'm curious to learn more about how that experience shapes a person!

I had way more conversations with random people on internet forums, IRC, etc. than my parents while growing up, and learned orders of magnitude more from those interactions... but they didn't feed, clothe, or house me so I would never claim I was raised by the 'net.

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#92

We are going to see a lot of children (and adults) raised by chatbots. Asking them for advice, confiding in them where real people don't seem safe, etc. Through the looking glass! Still, definitely better than asking Reddit for relationship advice

Rough seas ahead, thats for sure

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You give the impression here of having taken something I said quite personally. I hope I may be forgiven for not yet really understanding what or why. Likewise, my responses may be somewhat less on point for the distraction. The account under discussion is attributed public speech on the Internet. In other contexts, other conventions apply. There are about as many such contexts as there are kinds of relationships bet…

The bit I quoted seemed to be saying that curiosity and wanting to understand things are bad. Maybe that can be off topic and so out of place at work, but in online arguments prompted by something intentionally made public?

I'm talking about behavior. What motivates that behavior isn't relevant.

A nosy question is nosy because it demands an answer to which the querent is not entitled. Whether that undue desire is motivated by curiosity, prurience, arrogance, pity, or simple fascination - and I have seen all of these, sometimes in combination - has no bearing on the effect of the question on the one so asked. The vice inheres in the asking, because that forces the choice between refusing to answer and arousing the ire of jilted entitlement, and giving you an answer you have already done much to suggest you are not prepared to understand.

Within acceptable error, everyone who ever tries to have this conversation from your side proceeds from here to umbrage at the idea their behavior within it is in any way either predictable or discreditable, owing to the purity of their intentions.

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#94
a beautiful post. it's really nice when we get posts like this here, just personally i find it very meaningful.

> But sometimes the employees there would give me the employee discount, I guess they realized I needed it.

that is such a heart-warming thing.

i would maybe argue the following point in the article:

> People whose work was not aimed at me in the slightest.

idk. i think that part of the point of being open is being open to possibilities. obviously no one can see the far-reaching consequences of their work when they set out to do it. but sometimes, people have hopes, i think, that their openness will create possibilities just like this article is describing.

> resources like w3schools,

i remember a long time back - maybe 15 years ago - i would occasionally read w3schools, and i had a coworker who would kind of turn up their nose at that site, they were kind of a snob about it. i knew enough then to realize it wasn't the best site for everything but out of insecurity after that person said that, i stopped reading it too. but it helped me, too. and i'm glad it helped you. i am starting to re-revise my opinion of that site.

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is nothing remotely similar. Have you noticed it's only in our cities you seem to really hear about the homeless poor? It isn't the corollary of overall population distribution that it might intuitively look like.

> Have you noticed it's only in our cities you seem to really hear about the homeless poor? It isn't the correlate of overall population distribution that it might intuitively look like. I don't see that claim anywhere in this comment chain though?

You keep reading me as if I mean to nitpick word by word and line by line. Please don't. I'm addressing the same questions the article does, and participating in the conversation to that end. Inventing minutiae over which to quibble does no one any good.

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#97
post #9

I grew up in a rural part of the United States. First got online in 1996 when I was 8 years old. The best thing that the Internet gave me was a way to talk to strangers from around the world and make friends with people who I would have never had a chance to interact with in person. In my 20s, it lead to real life friendships with people I had met online, which is really cool. I have used Couch Surfing to make friend…

20 years later, some of my closest friends are those I met in 97 in a MUD. I have other friends, of course, but it's notable that friendships have endured entirely online for twenty years. Some of those friends I've talked to every day, or every few days, for decades, but I've only seen once or twice IRL.

I played non-Steam CS in early 2000s and made friends there in a foreign country. Years later added to Steam, and continued staying in close contact. A decade later we both ended up at the West Coast and still chat daily to this day.

We even worked on projects and started some companies along the way.

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#98

Of course nothing on the internet is new, it just assumes a default culture and philosophy which is less prominent in real life. It would be interesting to pin early internet to a particular demographic. Is it 90s stem graduate students primarily in the US? Middle class engineers?

> It would be interesting to pin early internet to a particular demographic.

Well, what counts as "early"?

This says that fully half of US adults were online by y2k: https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/fact-sheet/internet-bro...

This is titled "Profile of computer owners in the 1990s" with data points for 1990 and 1997: https://www.bls.gov/mlr/1999/04/atissue.pdf

Re: Being Raised by the Internet

#99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your reading comprehension is being interrogated because, in speaking of the article as though it did not say several of the things it says, you make such questions seem necessary. You are being told that the question you asked is "not even wrong": it is without meaning and so not meaningfully answerable, because it could only be asked at all from such a fundamental ignorance of the American situation around poverty…

> in speaking of the article as though it did not say several of the things it says, you make such questions seem necessary. What specifically does it say that is being ignored? That the author happened to find things he hadn't gone looking for directly? > fundamental ignorance of the American situation around poverty Are you claiming that terrible parents are uniquely American, in a way that is incapable of being ex…

The idea that this man's past situation can reduce to "terrible parents" even as passing reference, is a better example than I could ever invent of why this conversation will end fruitlessly for you.

It isn't that I don't see the obvious and honest effort you're putting into trying to have it. I respect that. The problem still is, though, that you don't see the entire world of social support structures that have been so ever-present for you throughout your life that you're unable in any real way to imagine what a life in their total absence even looks like. And if that sounds like a description of a chicken/egg problem, that's because it is one.

For you maybe this is the first time trying to talk across that divide. For someone like me, it's usually anything but. It's hard to fairly blame us for getting to learn some idea of how that usually goes.

(That's why, for example, I know I'm probably coming off pretty harsh with this and am deliberately doing so anyway; if I tried to go easier, we'd just take longer to still end up in the same place.)

Post reply on HN