Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

andrewhy.de

91–100 of 143 posts

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#91
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not $3 to transmit a file. It's $3 to: Design a great UX Handle Credit Cards safely Give you access to a robust infrastructure that won't crash Market the site Build and research a top quality e-Reader Build data centers all around the world etc etc etc Bottom line is the guy made WAY more selling with Kindle/Amazon than with any other format, even given their large cut. That didn't just happen by magic. He is f…

No, it is indeed $3 to transmit a file. They even call it a "delivery fee". Consider that the percentage cut they take should cover all of the above. I can get a physical pizza delivered for less than Amazon charges to send me an electronic file. That's just messed up. Hell, I can get physical goods delivered, from Amazon, with 2 day shipping, for less than they charge to send an electronic file! And how much do you…

If it bothers you so much, you are free to not use Amazon. It's not like they have a monopoly in the eReader market. What exactly am I missing here?

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#92
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

$3 to transmit 15 megabytes is fucking absurd, regardless of the delivery medium. Full stop, end of story.

It's not $3 to transmit a file. It's $3 to: Design a great UX Handle Credit Cards safely Give you access to a robust infrastructure that won't crash Market the site Build and research a top quality e-Reader Build data centers all around the world etc etc etc Bottom line is the guy made WAY more selling with Kindle/Amazon than with any other format, even given their large cut. That didn't just happen by magic. He is f…

[deleted]

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#93
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article does not say that downloading it over your wi-fi connection will result in $2.58 in delivery fees. It says that the average delivery fee for the book was $2.58.

Amazon apply the fee regardless of delivery method. Check out the link posted by kennethcwilbur elsewhere in this thread. https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A29FL26O... Amazon charge $0.15/MB and the book was approximately 18MB in size.

I don't particularly approve of their pricing, but to be fair the book could be downloaded many times over 3G in the future included in that initial delivery cost.

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#94
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not $3 to transmit a file. It's $3 to: Design a great UX Handle Credit Cards safely Give you access to a robust infrastructure that won't crash Market the site Build and research a top quality e-Reader Build data centers all around the world etc etc etc Bottom line is the guy made WAY more selling with Kindle/Amazon than with any other format, even given their large cut. That didn't just happen by magic. He is f…

No, it is indeed $3 to transmit a file. They even call it a "delivery fee". Consider that the percentage cut they take should cover all of the above. I can get a physical pizza delivered for less than Amazon charges to send me an electronic file. That's just messed up. Hell, I can get physical goods delivered, from Amazon, with 2 day shipping, for less than they charge to send an electronic file! And how much do you…

Distribution platforms are not free, and Amazon is thought to sell the kindle at a loss.

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#95
post #77
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Over a cell phone network a user would pay about $0.27 to download a 18MB file. There is no way an author should have to pay an order of magnitude more.

What if you have a US kindle in say, the deserts of Australia? It's going to cost a LOT more than $.27. I mean a LOT.

Wrong - most deserts of Australia don't have any 3G access. But anywhere in Australia with 3G access (i.e. populated areas) all have the same data tariff, which is comparable to the US price.

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#96

OK, so for a $10 book, Amazon collects 30% for themselves, which is $3. For a 19MB download delivered via 3G to a Kindle, Sprint, the wireless carrier, charges .15/MB, or $2.85/19MB. This is paid to Sprint, not Amazon.com. The article errors by comparing this fee to the cost for server bandwidth using S3 to come up with his markup value, but S3 bandwidth covers the internet only and does not include fees involved wit…

I am confused as to why the author of the book paying for the download of the end user in the first place? If the end user decides to download it via 3G it should either come out of their existing data allowance or be billed to their phone bill...

... or alternatively they can download it over Wifi and neither the end user, Amazon or the author should pay for it?

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#97
The pricing scheme may explain why so many Kindle books have crappy lo-res images. Text is small (the whole bible is 5 MB == $0.75 delivery charge) but quality images, like in the travel book in the article, bulk it up.

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The terms are plainly outlined in this table right here, which I found after 10 seconds of Googling: https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A29FL26O...

It helps to know what you're googling to find. Amazon's documentation is a mess (IMO) with half of it in PDF or other inaccessible format (.mobi) so that it's easy to get confused and lost in the process, especially for a first time author doing this on the side.

"kindle direct publishing calculator" and it was the first hit for me.

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#99
post #73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article does not say that downloading it over your wi-fi connection will result in $2.58 in delivery fees. It says that the average delivery fee for the book was $2.58.

Amazon apply the fee regardless of delivery method. Check out the link posted by kennethcwilbur elsewhere in this thread. https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A29FL26O... Amazon charge $0.15/MB and the book was approximately 18MB in size.

And that fee would be more reasonable if Amazon allowed authors to provide optimised versions of their book suitable for e-readers that don't have high resolution colour screens.

Re: Amazon Digital Markup: 129,000%

#100

This is confusing. Here is someone with a FANTASTIC first outing of a book and he's whinging about it? The author raises $8K on Kickstarter, sells his book for $10, and is complaining that the 'gorilla' is taking a bigger percentage of the take? Using his numbers: of 73%/11%/12%/1% his money was $1117/$231/$333/$20 respectively. So he made three times as much money selling through Amazon as he did on the next closest…

Having a great time with the book, sorry if I came off as whining. A few notes. A high % of the KS money went into rewards (books printed averaged $20 shipped). I did make 3x though Amazon, but if I had gone through gumroad, I would have done double the revenue. Biggest tl;dr complaint is that as an avid reader of about a book a week I had no idea that authors paid both 30% of the total price plus the delivery fee. T…

Did you consider Lulu.com when you were deciding where to publish?
Post reply on HN