Live data from Hacker News

Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

bugzilla.mozilla.org

91–99 of 99 posts

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#91
post #17

They're also deleting downloaded .pdf whilst in private mode. Yes even when I click save as. It gets downloaded to my downloads folder and then sometimes it's deleted when I close the browser. Sometimes.

That's really worrying. Can you reproduce it?

Quite a lot of the time yes. But the existing bug tracker issue is full of comments and a disgruntled employee has locked further comments.

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#92
It happened to me two or tree times on Wikipedia. When selecting text and right click, the copy item was disabled, I restarted Firefox and the copy field was enabled. Is funny how I never stopped to think about it till now seeing this post.

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#93

From the bug report: 1. Open https://www.google.com/ in a tab 2. Open https://ftp.mozilla.org/pub/firefox/nightly/ in the same tab 3. Click on Go back button (or Alt+Left Arrow) 4. Click on Go forward button (Alt+Right Arrow) 5. Select some text 6. Right click It doesn't seem like it's a website doing something it shouldn't be and breaking RFC. It's really a bug in firefox. Also, the scope is very specific and kinda…

I'm able to reproduce this on vanilla Linux Mint, FF version 127.0.2.

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#94
post #48

Not sure why this is big news, big enough to be in the #1 spot right now. From reading the comments on the bug, it seems to be an issue that's hard to reliably reproduce, and -- despite how simple it sounds from the editorialized HN title -- it involves interactions between different parts of the browser, and it's hard to track down and fix. Nonetheless, there are some proposed fixes, and I expect a near-future relea…

>it seems to be an issue that's hard to reliably reproduce

You say that like the unreliability is the result of some extrinsic influence like the weather or unfair portrayal of the project by journalists and not a strong sign that the project has unmanageable tech debt or does not have the human resources necessary for the difficult task of competing with Chrome.

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#95

From the bug report: 1. Open https://www.google.com/ in a tab 2. Open https://ftp.mozilla.org/pub/firefox/nightly/ in the same tab 3. Click on Go back button (or Alt+Left Arrow) 4. Click on Go forward button (Alt+Right Arrow) 5. Select some text 6. Right click It doesn't seem like it's a website doing something it shouldn't be and breaking RFC. It's really a bug in firefox. Also, the scope is very specific and kinda…

I've recently switched from Firefox to Edge until they fix this bug. Every now and then I go back to Firefox hoping it'll be fixed, and then it bites me again.

Now you have 10 problems. But it's always a matter of choosing the problems you want, I guess.

I might argue that this is quite minor in the face of... well... a Microsoft controlled browser, but what do I know

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#96
post #38

I switched to Edge because of this bug.

"I got annoyed with the occasional inability to use the 'Copy' menu item and couldn't fathom training my muscle memory to instead use ctrl+c, so I switched to a browser that spies on me and actively ignores my consent." I really don't get how people work, sometimes. Stuff like this tells me the privacy fight is just completely unwinnable. It's not even that people don't care; people actively make choices that make th…

> Stuff like this tells me the privacy fight is just completely unwinnable

Mozilla has done so many things to weaken users' trust in it (like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39166801) that at this point many regard them as the least worst (rather than best) alternative to the competition when it comes to privacy and the open web.

I'd like to hope that Ladybird will give us a genuine alternative, but Google has ensured that current web standards are so complex that even MSFT (another megacap tech company) threw in the towel on maintaining their own browser engine.

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#97
> Per comment 72, the team responsible for this bug is working to fix it. More +1 and advocacy comments aren't helping that happen faster but are adding unnecessary noise to this bug. A reminder that there are etiquette expectations when interacting in Bugzilla - it's not a free-for-all discussion forum. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/page.cgi?id=etiquette.html

> I'm restricting comments to keep further discussion focused where it needs to be on fixing this bug and getting it into a shipping release as soon as can be reasonably done.

Re: Copy and Paste context menu entries sometimes disabled when they should not be

#98

From the bug report: 1. Open https://www.google.com/ in a tab 2. Open https://ftp.mozilla.org/pub/firefox/nightly/ in the same tab 3. Click on Go back button (or Alt+Left Arrow) 4. Click on Go forward button (Alt+Right Arrow) 5. Select some text 6. Right click It doesn't seem like it's a website doing something it shouldn't be and breaking RFC. It's really a bug in firefox. Also, the scope is very specific and kinda…

I am able to reproduce this but I noticed that Ctrl+C, Ctrl+V still work even though the `Copy` menu item was disabled. So it is a visual glitch, at least on my machine.

I've noticed this randomly lately. I think it's this bug anyways. The copy and paste menu items are disabled but ctrl-c/v works. On websites that make no sense to have it disabled.
Post reply on HN