Live data from Hacker News

The "3 standup questions" are terrible and need to die

morethancoding.com

91–93 of 93 posts

Re: The "3 standup questions" are terrible and need to die

#91
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is in contention with the usual developer gripe about being interrupted from focus. Sometimes the blocker is your teammate who doesn’t like interruptions. Or a junior has been told to or assumes they need to “figure it out” and wastes a bunch of time instead of asking.

> a junior has been told to or assumes they need to “figure it out” and wastes a bunch of time instead of asking. Often you don't even know. More than once I've discovered someone working on a complex problem - they were making progress so didn't realize that someone else already had a solution and so they could save days of effort by asking the right person the right question.

Right. My point is there's a cohort of people here who are like "dont bother me, I only check email/slack in the morning, need extended focus time". At least some of those people are the ones who might know a thing or too, but they breed a culture of discouraging even bringing an issue up.

Re: The "3 standup questions" are terrible and need to die

#92

Daily stand-ups are terrible and need to die.

Daily stand-ups are wonderful and need to be encouraged.

> Avram: (gestures at maxcoder4 and throwawaaarrgh) He's right, and he's right? They can't both be right.

> Tevye: You know... you are also right.

Re: The "3 standup questions" are terrible and need to die

#93
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are too specific, formulaic, and reek of management tactics. If you mean, "how's it going?", say, "how's it going?" As the wise Dr. Seuss said, "I meant what I said and I said what I meant."

Hows it going is too vague for many. Every ask a kid what they learned at school today? The answer is always "nothing", or silence. You need to ask a different question to get a good answer. Which is one reason look for and ask different questions - if may break someone out of a rut.

[dead]
Post reply on HN