Live data from Hacker News

Overthinking

aentan.com

91–96 of 96 posts

Re: Overthinking

#91
post #61

I hate to say this, but the article is complete bullcrap. Have you even seen the movie he references ? The protagonist is supposed to be this "naturally talented genius" who detests the bookish Indian academic education system, so throughout the film he takes potshots at the stuff he's taught in school, ultimately choosing to drop out without a degree until the Dean formally requests him to take the finals, upon whic…

I solved that thing in less than 2 minutes too, and bet my pinkie finger nobody would take more than 15 minutes to figure it out. There is some background of truth in the article, that most people lose the will to be creative (not the ability) over time. But it's over-generalizations galore.

You solved the problem easily because the article name was "overthinking" and it was saying that "children could do this".

You would be absolutely amazed at what that does to your problem solving ability. You actually stop over-thinking. You don't go to your advanced number-theory knowledge you may or may not have and you look for a simple solution.

Sorry, but everyone that read the article and then solved the problem is tainted.

Re: Overthinking

#92
post #29
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That was what I answered on Quora. But there is a simpler solution; baking a rectangular pizza and cutting rectangular pieces.

You guys are still overthinking it. The real answer is to tell the customer to go to hell.

You're no fun... Not one of the people that sends little messages like "draw me a dinosaur" on their delivery tips, huh?

Re: Overthinking

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I solved that thing in less than 2 minutes too, and bet my pinkie finger nobody would take more than 15 minutes to figure it out. There is some background of truth in the article, that most people lose the will to be creative (not the ability) over time. But it's over-generalizations galore.

You solved the problem easily because the article name was "overthinking" and it was saying that "children could do this". You would be absolutely amazed at what that does to your problem solving ability. You actually stop over-thinking. You don't go to your advanced number-theory knowledge you may or may not have and you look for a simple solution. Sorry, but everyone that read the article and then solved the proble…

I could not solve the problem and gave up after an hour. I gave the problem to my preschool child and they also could not figure it out. Since the article didn't provide a method for 'childifying' our minds I guess the only solution is suicide.

Re: Overthinking

#96
post #65
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't understand why you presume it's a need to defend and justify it to others. Getting a PhD from MIT isn't exactly a walk in the park, I imagine the person got it BECAUSE of a pleasure to tackle complicated problems in the first place. If I really enjoy dealing with complexity and you give me something really simple to do, well I'm gonna go ahead and have some fun with it. It's not a matter of justifying, it's j…

To clarify, I'm not saying over-engineering is a good thing. I'm saying there's a mismatch between the complexity of the problem and the desires/personality of the person having to solve it. Give the simple problem to people who valor elegance, minimalism, simplicity, and keep the MIT PhD for rocket surgery and stuff.

Rocket surgery is a field I dearly want to see created. :-D
Post reply on HN