Live data from Hacker News

All Pocket accounts will be converted to Firefox accounts

blog.mozilla.org

91–97 of 97 posts

Re: All Pocket accounts will be converted to Firefox accounts

#92
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Browsers shouldn't require accounts, and thankfully Firefox doesn't. But having a way to synchronize my passwords across all my devices is pretty important.

That’s what a password manager is for

Does your password manager require an account to sync between multiple machines?

Re: All Pocket accounts will be converted to Firefox accounts

#93
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If people are fine with telling Pocket what they read I don't believe the ads shown in Firefox require sending any browsing history to the web (whether to Firefox or anyone else). The mechanism used here is different. I do agree with you that pushing ads into the browser chrome by default is abhorrent (a judgment compounded with the fact that they initially pretended that these weren't ads).

Saving pages to Pocket tells Mozilla what you read though. Reading List did not.

The implication of the first paragraph was that this behavior applied to users by default. If it's effectively opt-in, it's hard to argue that this is Mozilla "willing to sacrifice their user's privacy and security" and that "telling Pocket what they read" was "shoved on everyone", if in fact it is a choice to have your browsing history sent to Mozilla.

Re: All Pocket accounts will be converted to Firefox accounts

#94
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Saving pages to Pocket tells Mozilla what you read though. Reading List did not.

The implication of the first paragraph was that this behavior applied to users by default. If it's effectively opt-in, it's hard to argue that this is Mozilla "willing to sacrifice their user's privacy and security" and that "telling Pocket what they read" was "shoved on everyone", if in fact it is a choice to have your browsing history sent to Mozilla.

Replacing a privacy compatible feature with a revenue generating privacy incompatible sacrificed privacy for revenue. And what you called the implication was your inference.

Re: All Pocket accounts will be converted to Firefox accounts

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good for you. Firefox accounts are optional.

Indeed. I happen to know this because I use Firefox on a daily basis and have never once been pestered to use one.

So a browser with accounts works for you. So your comment was irrelevant.

Re: All Pocket accounts will be converted to Firefox accounts

#97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed. I happen to know this because I use Firefox on a daily basis and have never once been pestered to use one.

So a browser with accounts works for you. So your comment was irrelevant.

Wow, you sure got me. You want a medal or something?
Post reply on HN