Live data from Hacker News

No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

news.ycombinator.com

91–100 of 107 posts

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

+1, I love google docs and also love markdown. If there was a shared markdown editor with the same collaborative features as google docs, i'd probably never use anything else.

Sounds a lot like something like Notion?

Notion is very sluggish and feels very unlike a markdown file-based system to me.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#92

Why store markdown files in Google Drive of all places and not a git repository? Google Drive, to me, is object storage with a consumer-friendly user interface. It does not sound like the right place for constantly-changing text files for which you'd want revision history and commit-oriented editing.

> Why store markdown files in Google Drive of all places and not a git repository? Git diffing doesn't play nice with paragraph-based prose.

Does it not? All of our docs are Markdown files maintained in GitHub and diffs have never been an issue. PRs in particular are great for collaborative updates because reviewers can jump straight to the paragraphs that changed instead of reading everything top to bottom.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"people who know what Markdown is" overlaps very much with "people who have to use google docs for work but would prefer a consistent editing experience". Basically every dev I know has to use either teams/sharepoint/office or google docs, but most are also more comfortable with using markdown and use it for technical docs. I'd love to have a google docs option of creating a "simple doc", that is backed by markdown a…

+1, I love google docs and also love markdown. If there was a shared markdown editor with the same collaborative features as google docs, i'd probably never use anything else.

Product with corporate lock-in, but Quip allows the user to use markdown in their documents, and export their documents into Markdown.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#95
It's definitely a workaround, but I use a Chrome extension to work around this a bit. I use "Markdown Here" to add a "turn Markdown text into rich formatted text" button to my Chrome bar:

https://markdown-here.com/

And then I use it on plain Markdown text in a GMail compose window. The rich formatted output it produces is useful for sending richly-formatted GMail messages, but it can also be copy-pasted into a Google Doc (e.g. via https://docs.new), and it comes out really nicely, including support for headers, sub-headers, links, code blocks, and the rest. The main issue is that this is a one-way process, but so long as you keep the .md source files somewhere else, this trick lets you share a richly-formatted doc with others for final commenting/editing/etc. in the GDocs interface.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#96

Simple: if you make your documents in Markdown, you won't be making them in Google Docs. Stuff made in Google Docs is sticky, increases your dependence on Google, and importantly has a valuable network effect due to their collaboration features. It is in Google's best interest to encourage you to rely on their proprietary services instead of offering you alternatives that allow you to switch provider easily. Addition…

It's a bit like asking why Markdown isn't supported in Microsoft Word or Apple Pages. Environmental lock-in.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#97

Simple: if you make your documents in Markdown, you won't be making them in Google Docs. Stuff made in Google Docs is sticky, increases your dependence on Google, and importantly has a valuable network effect due to their collaboration features. It is in Google's best interest to encourage you to rely on their proprietary services instead of offering you alternatives that allow you to switch provider easily. Addition…

"people who know what Markdown is" overlaps very much with "people who have to use google docs for work but would prefer a consistent editing experience". Basically every dev I know has to use either teams/sharepoint/office or google docs, but most are also more comfortable with using markdown and use it for technical docs. I'd love to have a google docs option of creating a "simple doc", that is backed by markdown a…

SharePoint pages can now be created with Markdown BTW. There is a Markdown web part out of the box. Not so sure how Markdown files themselves are handled though, pretty badly I suspect.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"people who know what Markdown is" overlaps very much with "people who have to use google docs for work but would prefer a consistent editing experience". Basically every dev I know has to use either teams/sharepoint/office or google docs, but most are also more comfortable with using markdown and use it for technical docs. I'd love to have a google docs option of creating a "simple doc", that is backed by markdown a…

+1, I love google docs and also love markdown. If there was a shared markdown editor with the same collaborative features as google docs, i'd probably never use anything else.

Dropbox Paper should meet your requirements. I tried switching to it a few years ago, but the problem is that the other people I'm collaborating with always want to use Google Docs, and when I'm writing a document by myself, I'd much rather just write to a local file.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#99
A lot of people making strategic arguments like “it’s for lock-in”. I don’t buy it; they ship features so slowly that even obvious basic product features to copy from Notion like infinite-scrolling pages only shipped last year IIRC.

They have a huge backlog of features that are catch-up to a strategically threatening disruptive competitor, and they can’t deliver those. Markdown support is below all that in priority.

Re: No Markdown support in Google Drive after all these years

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds a lot like something like Notion?

Notion is very sluggish and feels very unlike a markdown file-based system to me.

Agreed, I like certain aspects of Notion, but as a FE dev myself, I think what they’re trying to do is too complex. I don’t see how they could ever make it performant.
Post reply on HN