Live data from Hacker News

AMD Alveo V70 AI inference accelerator card

xilinx.com

91–94 of 94 posts

Re: AMD Alveo V70 AI inference accelerator card

#91
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The idea that senior leadership at AMD is unaware.. Senior leadership at AMD isn't dumb. Lets try this with another company: The idea that leadership at Lehmon Brothers is unaware of the fact that they are trading subprime loans is absurd! The leadership isnt dumb The Idea that leadership at Being is unaware of safety issues with 737 Max is absurd! How could you suggest that anyone outside boesing understands bette…

The fact that a couple of other companies have had dumb leadership in no way proves that AMD's is dumb. You're essentially claiming that because Lehman and Boeing had dumb leadership, all senior leadership at all companies is dumb (because there's nothing linking AMD to these other companies except that they're all companies). And that is an absurd claim.

I am not sure if they are dumb, the jury is still out, but your entire post is the textboom example of logical fallacy, appeal to authority.

You are claiming that AMD leadership is infalliable based on no evidence whatsoever. Thats whats absurd

Re: AMD Alveo V70 AI inference accelerator card

#93
post #68
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> AMD has finite resources, like any company, and they’ve been focusing on CPU/datacenter dominance Why can't large companies tap the investment market? E.g. they could sell bonds to fund it, borrow, etc.

Well they definitely can, and do. They have made the decision that the reward isn't worth the risk. The idea (not aiming at you here, you didn't say this) that senior leadership at AMD is unaware of NVIDIA's lead in this space, and haven't repeatedly considered whether to invest in competing, is absurd. Likewise the idea that anyone outside of AMD understands better than AMD does what it would take in terms of invest…

Can you guess why they would be putting hardware into the ML workspace field but not backing that up with equivalent software integration?

Re: AMD Alveo V70 AI inference accelerator card

#94
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah but no one can deny Lisa Su is an MVP and knows what she’s doing. She’s borderline overqualified for CEO of AMD IMO

> but no one can deny Lisa Su is an MVP and knows what she’s doing In her area. We have no real info on how proficient she is in other areas like ML.

I’m not sure that’s really a separate “area”. She understands ML as it pertains to hardware and software sales better than anyone in this thread.
Post reply on HN