Live data from Hacker News

My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

github.com

91–100 of 157 posts

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#91

Wow! I look forward to playing Microsoft Flight Simulator inside the Emulator inside the Microsoft Flight Simulator on the 80th year anniversary.

I came here to say the same thing, but I'm gonna be an optimist and say that we'll get it by the 50th anniversary, not the 80th. We'll have MSFS in a form of VR that is not ergonomically awkward so that this is all possible.

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can't believe 1982 was 40 years ago

I was a Junior in college! Programming in PL/1

I was 6 years old, 7 or 8 years away from acquiring a Commodore 64 and typing out my first code in BASIC from the back pages of a Compute! magazine... I'm an old man.

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#93

And how much did Microsoft pay he? There is a old comic (some years ago) about "paid exposure" of Oatmeal: https://theoatmeal.com/comics/exposure

It incorporates four copies of Microsoft Flight Simulator, so it's really their IP as well.

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#94
post #6

Strange that Microsoft used OP's project in their game, but didn't bother to let him know.

Yes, I was not informed about it. But I think that's fair. I didn't ask them either before I published the project. Please, don't make it a license issue. I developed it for fun.

Is the whole emulator your work? That's quite impressive.

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#95
post #85
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I was not informed about it. But I think that's fair. I didn't ask them either before I published the project. Please, don't make it a license issue. I developed it for fun.

Unfortunately, all things must become a license issue if licenses are to be taken seriously. License compliance is a binary condition, you either comply completely or fail.

[deleted]

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#96
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about "The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software."?

Most likely, it is included in some kind of ThirdPartyNotices.txt that ships with the game. It's actually pretty hard to sneak third party F/OSS under the radar in the company of this size - there's automated code scanners, among other things, and while they can't catch everything, they sure can flag a copy of a public project on GitHub.

What's an example of tool that scans binaries for matches with open source software?

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#97
post #19

Strange that Microsoft used OP's project in their game, but didn't bother to let him know.

Microsoft is not the developer here, it has been outsourced to a game studio : https://www.asobostudio.com/games/microsoft-flight-simulator But the remark still stand, and I hope OP has been correctly credited for it.

Strange that Microsoft's contractor used OP's project in their game, but didn't bother to let him know.

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#98
post #96
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most likely, it is included in some kind of ThirdPartyNotices.txt that ships with the game. It's actually pretty hard to sneak third party F/OSS under the radar in the company of this size - there's automated code scanners, among other things, and while they can't catch everything, they sure can flag a copy of a public project on GitHub.

What's an example of tool that scans binaries for matches with open source software?

I don’t think you’ll find one. Most of these operate on the source code and its declared dependencies.

Re: My project is now an easter egg in Microsoft Flight Simulator

#99
post #97
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Microsoft is not the developer here, it has been outsourced to a game studio : https://www.asobostudio.com/games/microsoft-flight-simulator But the remark still stand, and I hope OP has been correctly credited for it.

Strange that Microsoft's contractor used OP's project in their game, but didn't bother to let him know.

Why is that strange?
Post reply on HN