See my reply to the sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30665186 I don't know about the current Samsung situation, but there were multiple phones by multiple vendors where whitelisting apps wasn't possible at all, or where it simply didn't work properly.

As DontKillMyApp notes, "the latest feedback suggests even when you remove an app from the restricted list, Samsung may re-add them later after a firmware update or when it thinks it is using too much resources". That is horrible.