Live data from Hacker News

Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

old.reddit.com

91–100 of 381 posts

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#91
post #69
post #12

How do you disable your old phones especially those those that do not work (due to shattered screen mostly) before giving them up for recycling or buyback? I am always worried someone will fix and misuse my old phone.

Factory reset Android will securly wipe the data.

That doesn't help if the phone is broken. My personal policy is to just keep all of my old devices (and hard drives, for that matter) forever.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#92

Wait! Text was deleted. How can we know this is legit?

Unddit is pretty good to read deleted or moderated posts as long as the deleted text was up long enough - https://www.unddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/r632w5/sent_my...

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#93
post #12

How do you disable your old phones especially those those that do not work (due to shattered screen mostly) before giving them up for recycling or buyback? I am always worried someone will fix and misuse my old phone.

If I can't properly wipe the phone I just keep it until I can fully destroy it. Same with old hard drives.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#94
post #12

How do you disable your old phones especially those those that do not work (due to shattered screen mostly) before giving them up for recycling or buyback? I am always worried someone will fix and misuse my old phone.

Keep PIN protection enabled - the storage on modern phones is encrypted by default and it's usually not possible to recover data without having the original PIN (unless you set it to something obvious like 0000).

Both iPhones and Android will HEAVILY complain in your setup process if you refuse to secure them with a PIN or a password.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#95
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seriously? You're blaming the victim?

Somebody: "I can't believe it! I like to leave stacks of $100 bills on the seat in my car and my car keeps getting broken into. Outrageous!" Somebody else: "You should probably take or hide the cash when you get out of your car." Offering wisdom for how to avoid a bad situation twice is not the same thing as blaming the victim.

A better analogy is a mechanic stealing money out of your car. And not money on view either, some place they'd have to look for it like in the visor.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#96
post #54

We need to educate people on how to secure the data on their phones so that even the manufacturer cannot reach it. And if that is not possible for a particular device, that should be clearly understood so people can make an informed choice about what smartphone they use. Can't just tell people 'do not put nudes on your phone' because while it's good advice, it misses the point. And, of course, whoever does something…

No. We don't need to "educate" people on how to magically dodge evil behavior. We need to punish the evil behavior. Like you said in your last sentence.

We need both.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#97
post #63

And people wonder why Apple wants to try to keep control of iPhone repair processes. This is one of the big reasons why.

I'm sure it's this and not the extra profit on increase new device sales and significantly higher cost of "original" replacement parts.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#98

I'm sick of people, so I'm not going to read the inevitable comments that are going to come. Look, face it, some people like taking nude photos of themselves and they like sharing them with their partners. There is absolutely nothing wrong with this. It's not their fault if something like this happens. People should be able to feel secure in the tech that they use, in the companies that they entrust their information…

I agree completely that you should be able to take nude photos of yourself, but I still wouldn't use a phone to do it -- my phone's pictures get backed up to the cloud automatically, and even if they didn't, the phone provider is probably the least likely risk that I face. I am probably more at risk from some rogue app that I installed on my phone.

When I have done this in the past, we did it the old fashioned way -- took the pics with a non-connected digital camera, printed the ones we liked, then kept the rest on an encrypted USB drive. Even this has the risk of leaking your photos to the cloud if your computer is set up for cloud backup.

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#99
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Taking precautions is what you do (in this case, if you can afford to do so) in order to prevent bad things happening to you. It is NOT what you do in order to determine fault if a bad thing DOES happen.

I don't see a contradiction here. It's terrible that Google allowed this to happen, and the individuals responsible should be held to account. Also, it is a good idea to be very protective of nude photos. I found the original comment useful for thinking about how I could avoid this situation personally.

It's a great thing to teach your children.

Not to tell adults after their privacy has been violated.

Do you really find it a useful comment? Was it not an immediately obvious conclusion that none of this would have happened if they had just fired their phone into outer space rather than hope to have their warranty honored?

Re: Pixel sent to Google for replacement. They used it to post wife's nudes online

#100
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah this is yet another reason to want phones to have removable storage (micro sd card). So private photos can go onto the card instead of built-in storage, and you can remove the card if you have to send in the phone. I don't take nudes but I tend to use my phone as an impromptu photocopier for stuff like bills and receipts, so the photos are full of private info such as account numbers. I worry about that sometime…

I feel like removable SD card is a tech person solution but ... kinda doesn't solve it for a lot of folks. Most folks are just going to take nudes and not strategize much and expect them to remain private as part of the typical photo taking and sharing workflow.

> I feel like removable SD card is a tech person solution but ... kinda doesn't solve it for a lot of folks.

What's so tech about removing a physical piece that has data? It's an action pretty much everyone can understand intuitively - "this is where your pictures are, if you remove it they stay yours".

Post reply on HN