Live data from Hacker News

Activist arrested by London police after downloading docs found on Google search

theregister.com

91–94 of 94 posts

Re: Activist arrested by London police after downloading docs found on Google search

#91
post #65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I personally think it's fair enough, the company claimed it was secure, therefore he hacked them. The police reacted, but when he could show it clearly it is absolutely not fair. The fair would be if the company had to show before the arrest that it was minimally secure. I mean they for sure had the HTTP transaction in their own logs - like GET document, response 200. They couldn't have reasonably in good faith clai…

Firstly, all those logs can be easily falsified and you're got absolutely no clue at all what that company showed to the police to convince them. So get off your extremely manufactured high horse. Secondly, even if you could somehow wave a magic wand and know the logs were real, you're approaching this as an expert and not as a layman. A crime was reported, it was followed up, an arrest was made (maybe that means som…

>It's just an arrest

I wonder how many people who say, "just an arrest" have actually been through being arrested.

Re: Activist arrested by London police after downloading docs found on Google search

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> So they're name dropping Google in the title for clickbait No, Hutchinson found the documents by searching on Google for the meeting minutes. The website might have protected the place where you found the link to the meeting minutes, but the meeting minutes themselves were hosted in a directory that not only was publicly accessible if you had the URL, but also allowed Google's crawler to access it and store it. The…

Police statement from the article: He was taken into custody and later released under investigation. Following a review of all available evidence, it was determined no offences had been committed and no further action was taken So they already dropped it.

> So they already dropped it.

Don't you agree that's totally irrelevant? Being arrested for downloading a random doc from the internet is a real problem, so as monitoring dissidents to persecute them for any reason at all.

Re: Activist arrested by London police after downloading docs found on Google search

#93
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t know mate, even if there is only the potential for a dangerous crime, we need to keep these criminals off our communication infrastructure until we know for certain. Perhaps a better idea is a public/private partnership between all the big search engines, social media companies and police organizations who want to join and can pay dues. Information sharing between members of the federation would reduce crime…

Would you still hold this opinion if all your personal computing devices are held for multiple weeks based on any arbitrary allegation and the record of your false arrest is available to all future employers ?

> Would you still hold this opinion (...)

I'm sure the post reads as satire.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal

Re: Activist arrested by London police after downloading docs found on Google search

#94
post #93
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would you still hold this opinion if all your personal computing devices are held for multiple weeks based on any arbitrary allegation and the record of your false arrest is available to all future employers ?

> Would you still hold this opinion (...) I'm sure the post reads as satire. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal

I’m delighted to learn this is a genre of writing that even exists. Perhaps there is hope for us after all.
Post reply on HN