Live data from Hacker News

VMWare Screw Customers

communities.vmware.com

91–93 of 93 posts

Re: VMWare Screw Customers

#91
post #81

Why use proprietary (less tested, less stable) solutions while there is community-tested and community-supported ones? ^_^ People still stuck with a stereotype that most brilliant programmers work for corporations. This is, obviously, not true. Most of corporations outsource their R&D and QA and spend for marketing instead. That is a very common strategy. Now tell me - how this strategy correlates with a quality of a…

> One cannot compete with Linux (Ubuntu/RHEL/CentOS) communities in matters of testing and code quality. No code is better tested than those included in mainstream kernel or a polular distribution. I know I'm feeding the troll here, but that is just naive. There are many great open-source projects with terrific code quality, like parts of (and certainly not the whole of) the Linux kernel. There are also many commerci…

You doing what?

Yes, there are many this or that, but in general, Open Source model works just because it is community driven. That means if your project or some critical part of it (scheduler or implementation of TCP) is really important to users it will receive almost constant code reviews ans quality improvements. This was the story behind nginx, openssh and thousands more.

Of course, some parts of project might be considered less relevant and users are satisfied with code that just works.

One can achieve better code quality than fanatics, nerds or very experienced programmers could show only by hiring such people for doing what they like to do. Mediocre wage-workers can't produce anything near it. Look at nginx's or openbsd's or postfix sources.

Please, try to imagine number of installations of both products. mySQL runs on almost every crappy hosting in the world. And on Facebook. ^_^

I don't way to say that mySQL is great product. What I want to say is that it is good enough and stable enough. Otherwise there will be no usage of it.

btw, outsourcing is all about cost reduction, not quality increase. ^_^

Re: VMWare Screw Customers

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

VMware has had some significant management changes: http://managementaschangeagent.blogspot.com/2008/07/update-t... so you are maybe right about the MBA, non-founder thinking at the C-level there. Compare VMware's 20110331 net income to 20101231 net income: https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE:VMW&fstype=ii - note how it has flattened. Since VMware is public quarterly results are vital to the naive MBA. Said MBA mig…

Amazon uses Xen, they probably don't pay VMware or Citrix for any licensing.

They don't. Amazon is built off the FOSS version of Xen - http://xen.org/

Re: VMWare Screw Customers

#93
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agreed - though, if open source is gonna kill the golden goose regardless... maybe might as well kill it first, get all the eggs.

The other scenario is that keeping prices reasonable means there isn't as much demand for an open source version. Developers who balked at paying $150 a seat wouldn't be sufficiently motivated if the cost was a more "reasonable" $20 say.

I just remembered a pretty good example of this with the story of BitKeeper and Git, you can read http://kerneltrap.org/node/4966 for more information. It was the catalyst of losing the cheap enough/free option that motivated the work on Git.
Post reply on HN