Live data from Hacker News

Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

linkedin.com

91–100 of 145 posts

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes? Isn't the common advice that you should have multiple offers in hand before giving notice? Or do you give notice without an offer?

The middle ground here, and what most people do, is giving notice when you have one (1) offer in hand. You shouldn't need multiple

Do you not negotiate between companies who've given you offers? That's standard advice for tech workers that I've heard and used.

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes? Isn't the common advice that you should have multiple offers in hand before giving notice? Or do you give notice without an offer?

If you're hoping to negotiate a counter from your current employer maybe you should have multiple, it probably gives you a stronger hand. If you're leaving either way why would you? And this isn't about 0 offers vs. many, it's 1 offer vs. many.

You'd negotiate between the companies that gave you offers, not between you and your current employer, although you can do that too but it's not recommended, due to them knowing you'll leave.

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#93
post #50
post #36

This is sadly a lot more common than people realize. It's drilled in your head that as an employee you should never ever renege on a job offer or accept a better one too soon because you are "burning bridges" and that is very bad, but it never works the same the other way around. Budgets change all the time. Departments go through reorgs. Projects get cancelled. "Hey but we have an open job offer" is never going to b…

Yeah, been there, done that. I turned down my other offers and then the one I accepted cancelled on me the night before my first day of work. I ran out of money and had to take a loan from a friend. I ended up working for them later anyway. No point holding a grudge.

It’s not about holding a grudge, it’s a loss of trust. If an employer did this to me, I wouldn’t trust them to not fuck me over in other ways as an employee.

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel for this candidate and I’m sorry he has to go through this. However, candidates aren’t innocent in all of this either. I’ve been on the other side in the hiring seat where candidates accept an offer and then cancel in the days leading up to starting. This comes after closing out the remaining candidate pipeline and telling potentially qualified candidates that the position was filled. It’s not a good look to h…

And when they do that, do you not consider it wrong?

How is it wrong?

Company A makes an offer for a job on June 1 with a start date of June 15 and a salary of 100.

Company B makes an offer for a job on June 5 with a start date of June 20 and salary of 130.

Should you say, I'm sorry company B., your offer is much better, but I already took the lesser offer?

Yes, I'm sure _some_ people would turn down a 30% diff., but most people will not and I would not hold that against them. If anything, it's good for you because be assured this person will not stay long at your co knowing they can potentially earn more, all things being equivalent.

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also, emoployees can leave company any time. And they leave companies on short notices! Cuts both ways!

Are there actually countries where employees can't quit if they want to?

In Germany default regulation (§622 BGB) is 4 weeks towards 15th or last day of month, but I've seen 2 or 3 months contracts, for senior management even 6 months (rare though). Often the first 6 months of employment are on probation and only 2 weeks notice are neccessary.

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#96
post #36

This is sadly a lot more common than people realize. It's drilled in your head that as an employee you should never ever renege on a job offer or accept a better one too soon because you are "burning bridges" and that is very bad, but it never works the same the other way around. Budgets change all the time. Departments go through reorgs. Projects get cancelled. "Hey but we have an open job offer" is never going to b…

It may be culturally dependent but I would argue that in many countries not keeping a promise, especially in business has its costs both for the company and societal trust(1)

If there is a level of uncertainty, then I would argue that it should be stated clearly to be fair to the prospective employee so that the concerned person can make an informed choice.

If Tesla, or other companies misuse their leverage and information asymmetry for their advantage, I would further argue in favour of laws that make these practices more difficult and more transparent so that everyone can learn from the process and know what risks they are taking

(1)

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#97
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't this promissory estoppel? Like they promised that you would start at a certain date, causing you to quit your current job. Then they withdrew the promise, causing you to be unemployed.

A clever tatic to remove key employees from competitors.

Right. You can promise whatever exhorbitant amount of money, perks and projects that dont exist . One day before the start date you just rescind the fictional offer.

This is so unethical there should be a 1 or 2 month "deposit" for these cases haha

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This kinda goes against what OP is against though, no? If you have multiple offer letters, chances are multiple other companies have stopped their job search (especially if they don't want to lead on other candidates).

Not necessarily, sometimes companies will oversubscribe to offers, ie hand out multiple offers but only take one of them, because they know many people could decline so they don't want to be stuck with no one. Same philosophy on the employee side, not beneficial to ride everything on only one offer.

I guess it's time to start insisting that signing bonus doesn't have a 1 year cliff

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#99
At the very least, Tesla should pay the author for the time between the hire date through until two weeks after the notice the position was eliminated.

Also, it's not like they couldn't use another SWE. Unless the applicant was a specialist, I see no reason they couldn't just train for another position doing similar work, unless the application would prefer not to.

From now on, employees should feel very comfortable leaving Tesla with zero notice.

Re: Tesla Rescinds Job Offer

#100
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, that doesn’t match my expectation at all. Does that commenter think that you should always have multiple job offers before giving notice to your current job?

Yes? Isn't the common advice that you should have multiple offers in hand before giving notice? Or do you give notice without an offer?

I've been working for 20 years and I've had 6 different jobs. I have never once had multiple simultaneous offers for new jobs. In my experience it's been offer; acceptance; agree on start date; then give notice.
Post reply on HN