Live data from Hacker News

ReactOS Updates

reactos.org

91–100 of 142 posts

Re: ReactOS Updates

#91
post #38
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is false. There was an issue when there was a leak of windows source code to the internet, and ReactOS effectively had to shut down development for months while all code was audited to make sure no helpful folks had used any of it to 'help' the project. That's the only MS IP controversy they've been involved in (and I've been watching the project for waaaay too many years now) (That issue answer reads like someo…

The specific issue is;: > Many internal data structures and internal functions, not exported anywhere and not part of the public symbols, have the exact same names as they appear in the Research Kernel (which, by the way, is quite obsolete). There is an almost surely zero probability that this happened, at that scale, by accident. Unfortunately I don’t think anyone who doesn’t have access to the research kernel is ca…

He didn't know that Microsoft had shipped private symbols publicly by accident several times.

Re: ReactOS Updates

#92

What is ReactOS's endgame? It seems they will never have enough resources to become more popular than windows. And they will never manage to become the desktop OS of choice over Linux or Mac either. It seems to sit in an odd place with only a tiny userbase and no real goal, permanently playing catchup.

ReactOS should be pretty interesting for any Windows shop. If you have some in house app and you can run it in reactos, you can stop paying licences.

Re: ReactOS Updates

#95

What is ReactOS's endgame? It seems they will never have enough resources to become more popular than windows. And they will never manage to become the desktop OS of choice over Linux or Mac either. It seems to sit in an odd place with only a tiny userbase and no real goal, permanently playing catchup.

How much of the windows churn over the past decade has been widely accepted as good by the users? They only really need to get to a XP64/win7 level of win32 capability with the ability to run a recent graphics stack and they will win. They have been getting closer to the "just" works bit every year. At some point I suspect their market share will start to rise enough that application vendors start assuring their prog…

I have been as skeptical as the parent post. You make a good point though. Getting to Windows 7 at any point this decade will give them a real shot at increasing user base. I assume most people would be happy on Windows 7 as on Windows 10 outside of becoming comfortable on Windows 10 over the past 5 yrs

Re: ReactOS Updates

#96
post #13

I really hope the integration with QubesOS[1] will be completed in the near future. It will allow to run suspicious legacy Windows software without any hassle. [1] https://github.com/QubesOS/qubes-issues/issues/2809

Anyone do this with WINE and Qubes? I've found WINE to be more stable than ReactOS.

Re: ReactOS Updates

#98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ReactOS denies those accusations. If it's true and proved, probably users should stop using it, but until it's proved, I don't think that it's an issue. Like you've got some software, you checked its license, it's open source reimplementation of Windows, sounds good. For example Valve uses wine to run games on Linux, it's pretty legit.

WINE and ReactOS are separate projects and the allegations in the Quora post are specific to ReactOS. WINE doesn't handle NT kernel internals; it reimplements public Windows APIs and proxies kernel functionality to the host userland (usually GNU+Linux+X11 but occasionally Darwin+AppKit). The main existential threat to WINE would be the Oracle/Google case being decided (sometime before June). If that winds up creating…

Let's do the reverse: call out BSD folks and sue everyone for using the C API + BSD networking.

Re: ReactOS Updates

#99
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wine tends to have far higher compatibility, and the operating system it runs on top of is mature too. ReactOS is a cool project, but it's an alpha-stage complete operating system with bugs as basic in nature as you shouldn't even expect the file system to live long without being corrupted, or the OS crashing constantly. Not to mention they primarily focus on Windows XP compatibility, Vista and newer software is gene…

From that, it sounds like ReactOS already provides the classic Windows experience!

Non-joking: it's probably about on par with Windows 98 when it comes to stability.

There was a day people accepted that sort of thing... but not anymore.

Post reply on HN